Processing math: 7%
Research article Special Issues

A novel analysis of the time-fractional nonlinear dispersive K(m, n, 1) equations using the homotopy perturbation transform method and Yang transform decomposition method

  • Received: 28 August 2023 Revised: 23 November 2023 Accepted: 07 December 2023 Published: 18 December 2023
  • MSC : 26A33, 35A20, 35L05

  • The main features of scientific effort in physics and engineering are the development of models for various physical issues and the development of solutions. In this paper, we investigate the numerical solution of time-fractional non-linear dispersive K(m, n, 1) type equations using two innovative approaches: the homotopy perturbation transform method and Yang transform decomposition method. Our suggested approaches elegantly combine Yang transform, homotopy perturbation method (HPM) and adomian decomposition method (ADM). With the help of the Yang transform, we first convert the problem into its differential partner before using HPM to get the He's polynomials and ADM to get the Adomian polynomials, both of which are extremely effective supports for non-linear issues. In this case, Caputo sense is used for defining the fractional derivative. The derived solutions are shown in series form and converge quickly. To ensure the effectiveness and applicability of the proposed approaches, the examined problems were analyzed using various fractional orders. We analyze and demonstrate the validity and applicability of the solution approaches under consideration with given initial conditions. Two and three dimensional graphs reflect the outcomes that were attained. To verify the effectiveness of the strategies, numerical simulations are presented. The numerical outcomes demonstrate that only a small number of terms are required to arrive at an approximation that is exact, efficient, and trustworthy. The results of this study demonstrate that the studied methods are effective and strong in solving nonlinear differential equations that appear in science and technology.

    Citation: Abdul Hamid Ganie, Fatemah Mofarreh, Adnan Khan. A novel analysis of the time-fractional nonlinear dispersive K(m, n, 1) equations using the homotopy perturbation transform method and Yang transform decomposition method[J]. AIMS Mathematics, 2024, 9(1): 1877-1898. doi: 10.3934/math.2024092

    Related Papers:

    [1] Mahmoud El-Morshedy, Mohamed S. Eliwa, Mohamed El-Dawoody, Hend S. Shahen . A weighted hybrid discrete probability model: Mathematical framework, statistical analysis, estimation techniques, simulation-based ranking, and goodness-of-fit evaluation for over-dispersed data. Electronic Research Archive, 2025, 33(4): 2061-2091. doi: 10.3934/era.2025091
    [2] Weishang Gao, Qin Gao, Lijie Sun, Yue Chen . Design of a novel multimodal optimization algorithm and its application in logistics optimization. Electronic Research Archive, 2024, 32(3): 1946-1972. doi: 10.3934/era.2024089
    [3] Shaban Khidr, Salomon Sambou . Lp-theory for the ¯-equation and isomorphisms results. Electronic Research Archive, 2025, 33(1): 68-86. doi: 10.3934/era.2025004
    [4] Shuai Chang, Jinrui Guan . A study on the estimator for the extreme value index of heavy-tailed distribution generated from moment statistic. Electronic Research Archive, 2025, 33(4): 2295-2311. doi: 10.3934/era.2025101
    [5] Hanan H. Sakr, Mohamed S. Mohamed . On residual cumulative generalized exponential entropy and its application in human health. Electronic Research Archive, 2025, 33(3): 1633-1666. doi: 10.3934/era.2025077
    [6] Caiwen Chen, Tianxiu Lu, Ping Gao . Chaotic performance and circuitry implement of piecewise logistic-like mapping. Electronic Research Archive, 2025, 33(1): 102-120. doi: 10.3934/era.2025006
    [7] Sadia Anwar, Showkat Ahmad Lone, Aysha Khan, Salmeh Almutlak . Stress-strength reliability estimation for the inverted exponentiated Rayleigh distribution under unified progressive hybrid censoring with application. Electronic Research Archive, 2023, 31(7): 4011-4033. doi: 10.3934/era.2023204
    [8] Xuerui Li, Lican Kang, Yanyan Liu, Yuanshan Wu . Distributed Bayesian posterior voting strategy for massive data. Electronic Research Archive, 2022, 30(5): 1936-1953. doi: 10.3934/era.2022098
    [9] Zhensheng Zhou, Lin Wang, Xue Zou, Fei Wang, Zaijun Zhang, Xiaobo Yan . The first hitting time analysis of evolutionary algorithms based on renewal process. Electronic Research Archive, 2024, 32(5): 2994-3015. doi: 10.3934/era.2024137
    [10] Xin Gao, Hao Liu, Zhou Fang, Yang Zhang . Microscopic mechanism of subgrade vibration compaction based on discrete element method. Electronic Research Archive, 2023, 31(11): 7061-7077. doi: 10.3934/era.2023358
  • The main features of scientific effort in physics and engineering are the development of models for various physical issues and the development of solutions. In this paper, we investigate the numerical solution of time-fractional non-linear dispersive K(m, n, 1) type equations using two innovative approaches: the homotopy perturbation transform method and Yang transform decomposition method. Our suggested approaches elegantly combine Yang transform, homotopy perturbation method (HPM) and adomian decomposition method (ADM). With the help of the Yang transform, we first convert the problem into its differential partner before using HPM to get the He's polynomials and ADM to get the Adomian polynomials, both of which are extremely effective supports for non-linear issues. In this case, Caputo sense is used for defining the fractional derivative. The derived solutions are shown in series form and converge quickly. To ensure the effectiveness and applicability of the proposed approaches, the examined problems were analyzed using various fractional orders. We analyze and demonstrate the validity and applicability of the solution approaches under consideration with given initial conditions. Two and three dimensional graphs reflect the outcomes that were attained. To verify the effectiveness of the strategies, numerical simulations are presented. The numerical outcomes demonstrate that only a small number of terms are required to arrive at an approximation that is exact, efficient, and trustworthy. The results of this study demonstrate that the studied methods are effective and strong in solving nonlinear differential equations that appear in science and technology.



    The features and interrelationships of distribution functions are important for representing naturally occurring events. The conventional distributions, however, have not been able to adequately describe complex data due to the dynamic and ever-increasing complexity of current datasets. Aware of these limitations, scientists have focused their attention on improving the effectiveness and suitability of these distributions in an attempt to find better matches for the variety of real-world information. There are several approaches for defining statistical distributions. Different approaches are available for defining failure rate and density functions to create distributions with more desired and modifiable qualities. One of these approaches is the development of generated families of the probability distributions. Notable has helped to create new distribution families that aim to solve the shortcomings of their earlier versions. Recently, a variety of academics have developed an interest in the families of distributions that have been generated, such as the Marshall Olkin-G proposed by Ref. [1], beta-G presented by Ref. [2], transformed- transformer (T-X) family proposed by Ref. [3], Topp-Leone-G prepared by Ref. [4], new Topp Leone-G prepared by Ref. [5], transmuted odd Fréchet-G created by Ref. [6], modified T-X family prepared by Ref. [7], truncated power Lomax-G proposed by Ref. [8], odd Lindley-G, and power Lindley-G discussed, respectively, by [9,10]. For more recently generated families, the reader can refer to [11,12,13,14].

    Nowadays, there has been a lot of interest in the families represented by "trigonometric transformations" due to their versatility and ability for modeling a variety of real-world datasets. The sine-G (S-G) family of distributions, which was first presented by Ref. [15], is the first trigonometric family. The cumulative distribution function (CDF) of the S-G family is as follows:

    G(t;ζ)=sin(12πF(t;ζ)),tR, (1.1)

    where F(t;ζ) is the baseline CDF of a continuous distribution and ζ is a parameter vector. The following is the probability density function (PDF) associated with CDF (1.1):

    g(t;ζ)=12πf(t;ζ)cos(12πF(t;ζ)),tR, (1.2)

    where f(t;ζ) is the PDF corresponding to F(t;ζ). As indicated in Ref. [16], the S-G family offers several benefits, such as the following, (ⅰ) It is straightforward; (ⅱ) the CDF G(t;ζ) and the CDF F(t;ζ) have the same number of parameters that is, no extra parameter is used therefore, there is no risk of over-parameterization; (ⅲ) the trigonometric function enables G(t;ζ) to expand F(t;ζ)'s flexibility, resulting in the creation of new flexible models.

    One popular lifespan model that was created by Ref. [17] is the half logistic distribution (HLD). It has attracted significant interest due to its simplicity, tractable mathematical features, and capacity to accommodate survival data. Basically, the HLD is characterized by the survival function (SF) provided by

    S(y)=21+eδy;y,δ>0,

    where δ>0, is the scale parameter. Recently, a number of HLD generalizations and extensions have been proposed in an effort to increase or use some of its features. Among them are the inverse HLD [18], generalized HLD [19], exponentiated half logistic-G [20], McDonald-HLD [21], type Ⅱ half logistic-G [22], power- HLD [23], Kumaraswamy-HLD [24], Marshall-Olkin HLD [25], type Ⅰ half logistic Lindley distribution [26], transmuted-HLD [27], type Ⅱ half logistic Weibull distribution [28], half-logistic generalized Weibull distribution [29], type Ⅰ half logistic Burr X-G [30], modified-HLD [31], unit exponentiated-HLD [32], and, for more extended forms, refer to [33,34,35,36].

    The main focus here is on a more flexible model, the power-HLD (PHLD) with an extra shape parameter compared to HLD. The CDF and PDF, with scale parameter δ>0 and shape parameter γ>0 of the PHLD, are provided by:

    F(t;ζ)=121+eδtγ;t>0, (1.3)

    and

    f(t;ζ)=2δγtγ1eδtγ(1+eδtγ)2;t>0, (1.4)

    where ζ=(δ,γ).

    The requirement for flexible and efficient probability distributions is fundamental in statistics and probability theory. The fact that no one distribution fits every dataset makes academics constantly look for ways to improve the accuracy and flexibility of current models. In light of this, a new two-parameter distribution called the sine-PHLD (SPHLD) was created, which is based on the PHLD. The SPHLD is intended to efficiently simulate datasets with a range of asymmetrical shapes. The following motivates us to recommend the SPHLD.

    1) To enhance the versatility of the traditional PHLD in the modeling of different phenomena. The SPHLD can be used to model skewed data from a range of sources, including agricultural and survival times. Additionally, SPHLD performs better than other distributions that are available in the literature, according to our evaluation of its performance on actual data.

    2) A few SPHLD features are identified, including the quantile function (QF), moments (both full and incomplete), and stress-strength (SS) reliability.

    3) To evaluate the SPHLD parameters' behavior, sixteen estimation strategies are advised. The approaches that have been suggested include percentiles (PC), Kolmogorov, maximum product spacing (MPS), ordinary least squares (OLS), Anderson-Darling (AD), Cramér-von Mises (CVM), left tail AD (LTAD), minimum spacing square distance (MSSD), maximum likelihood (ML), weighted LS (WLS), minimum spacing absolute-log distance (MSALD), right-tail AD (RTAD), AD left tail second order (ADSO), minimum spacing Linex distance (MSLND), minimum spacing absolute distance (MSAD), and minimum spacing square log distance (MSSLD).

    4) A comprehensive simulation study is conducted to evaluate the behaviors of different estimators because it is challenging to compare them theoretically. Tables and graphs were included to demonstrate how these methods worked for different parameter values and sample sizes.

    5) In comparison to other current models, the SPHLD's adaptability makes it a competitive model for fitting real data. This study illustrates its efficacy by contrasting it with a number of well-known statistical models, such as the exponentiated generalized standard HLD, exponentiated HLD, Poisson generalized HLD, Kumaraswamy HLD, Type-Ⅱ half logistic Weibull distribution, and PHLD. Two practical applications from the fields of agriculture and medical science further demonstrate the SPHLD's superiority.

    This article has the following setup: A novel model extending the PHLD is presented in Section 2. The essential properties of the SPHLD distribution are obtained in Section 3. Many methods for estimating model parameters are covered in Section 4. Section 5 uses Monte Carlo simulations to conduct a numerical analysis. Two real datasets are quantitatively examined in Section 6, and the results are presented in Section 7.

    In this section, a relatively new flexible distribution model known as the SPHLD is created by setting CDF (1.3) into CDF (1.1). This allows us to get the CDF, which may be represented as

    F(t;ζ)=sin[12π(121+eδtγ)]=cos(π1+eδtγ);t,δ,γ>0, (2.1)

    where ζ=(δ,γ) is the set of parameters. The PDF of the SPHLD associated with (2.1) is given by:

    f(t;ζ)=δγπtγ1eδtγ(1+eδtγ)2sin(π1+eδtγ);t,δ,γ>0. (2.2)

    For γ=1, the PDF (2.2) reduces to the sine HLD (SHLD) as a new sub-model. The SF and hazard rate function (HRF) of the SPHLD are as below:

    S(t;ζ)=1cos(π1+eδtγ), (2.3)

    and

    h(t;ζ)=δγπtγ1eδtγ(1+eδtγ)2sin(π1+eδtγ)[1cos(π1+eδtγ)]1.

    The SPHLD can accurately represent the positively skewed, reverse J-shaped, and unimodal data (left panel in Figure 1) with varying failure rates and decreasing, increasing, and reverse J-shaped failure data (right panel in Figure 1) structures. Figure 2 shows the 3D plots of the PDF and HRF for the SPHLD at δ = 1.5.

    Figure 1.  Plots of PDF and HRF for the SPHLD.
    Figure 2.  The 3D plots of the PDF and HRF for the SPHLD at δ = 1.5.

    Several statistical features, including SS reliability, inverse moments, QF, and central moments, have been covered in the subsections that follow.

    The QF of the SPHLD is determined by inverting (2.1) as follows:

    Q(p)=[1δln(πcos1(p)1)]1/γ;0<p<1 (3.1)

    Specifically, by setting p = 0.25, 0.5, and 0.75, respectively, in (3.1), the first quartile, or Q1, the second quartile, or Q2, and the third quartile, or Q3, are achieved. Some numerical values of the proposed model quantiles are presented in Table 1.

    Table 1.  Some numerical values for the proposed model quantiles.
    Parameters Measures
    δ γ Q(0.1) Q(0.25) Q(0.35) Q(0.5) Q(0.6) Q(0.75) Q(0.85) Q(0.95)
    0.15 0.5 0.724887 4.68121 9.54363 21.3535 33.6724 64.8572 105.342 212.237
    1.0 0.851403 2.16361 3.08928 4.62098 5.80279 8.0534 10.2636 14.5684
    3.0 0.947789 1.29338 1.45642 1.66563 1.79699 2.00444 2.1732 2.44233
    5.0 0.968338 1.16691 1.25306 1.35815 1.42144 1.51773 1.59316 1.70876
    7.0 0.977281 1.11656 1.17484 1.24441 1.28556 1.34718 1.39467 1.46623
    10 0.984042 1.08023 1.1194 1.1654 1.19224 1.23196 1.26221 1.3072
    0.6 0.5 0.0453054 0.292575 0.596477 1.33459 2.10452 4.05357 6.58386 13.2648
    1.0 0.212851 0.540902 0.772319 1.15525 1.4507 2.01335 2.5659 3.64209
    3.0 0.59707 0.814779 0.917485 1.04928 1.13203 1.26272 1.36903 1.53857
    5.0 0.733863 0.884349 0.949641 1.02928 1.07725 1.15023 1.20739 1.295
    7.0 0.801698 0.915955 0.963765 1.02083 1.05459 1.10514 1.1441 1.2028
    10 0.856658 0.940398 0.974495 1.01454 1.03791 1.07249 1.09881 1.13798
    0.9 0.5 0.0201357 0.130033 0.265101 0.593152 0.935344 1.80159 2.92616 5.89547
    1.0 0.1419 0.360602 0.514879 0.770164 0.967132 1.34223 1.7106 2.42806
    3.0 0.521588 0.711775 0.801497 0.916631 0.988922 1.10309 1.19596 1.34406
    5.0 0.676701 0.815465 0.875671 0.94911 0.993338 1.06063 1.11335 1.19413
    7.0 0.75658 0.864407 0.909526 0.96338 0.995237 1.04294 1.07971 1.13511
    10 0.822618 0.903031 0.935773 0.974223 0.996664 1.02987 1.05515 1.09276
    1.5 0.5 0.00724887 0.0468121 0.0954363 0.213535 0.336724 0.648572 1.05342 2.12237
    1.0 0.0851403 0.216361 0.308928 0.462098 0.580279 0.80534 1.02636 1.45684
    3.0 0.439925 0.600334 0.676009 0.773116 0.834089 0.930379 1.00871 1.13363
    5.0 0.61098 0.736268 0.790626 0.856933 0.896866 0.957626 1.00522 1.07816
    7.0 0.703335 0.803573 0.845517 0.895581 0.925196 0.969546 1.00372 1.05522
    10 0.781652 0.85806 0.889172 0.925707 0.94703 0.978584 1.00261 1.03834
    2.5 0.5 0.00260959 0.0168523 0.0343571 0.0768725 0.121221 0.233486 0.37923 0.764053
    1.0 0.0510842 0.129817 0.185357 0.277259 0.348167 0.483204 0.615817 0.874101
    3.0 0.371047 0.506341 0.570168 0.652071 0.703498 0.784712 0.85078 0.956138
    5.0 0.551642 0.664762 0.713841 0.773708 0.809762 0.864622 0.907591 0.973447
    7.0 0.653837 0.747021 0.786013 0.832554 0.860085 0.901313 0.933086 0.980961
    10 0.742726 0.815329 0.844891 0.879607 0.899868 0.92985 0.952676 0.986634
    4.5 0.5 0.00080543 0.00520134 0.010604 0.0237261 0.0374137 0.0720635 0.117046 0.235819
    1.0 0.0283801 0.0721203 0.102976 0.154033 0.193426 0.268447 0.34212 0.485612
    3.0 0.305027 0.416248 0.468718 0.536049 0.578325 0.645088 0.699401 0.786013
    5.0 0.490459 0.591033 0.634669 0.687896 0.719951 0.768726 0.80693 0.865482
    7.0 0.601176 0.686855 0.722707 0.765499 0.790813 0.828721 0.857935 0.901954
    10 0.700328 0.768787 0.796661 0.829395 0.848499 0.87677 0.898293 0.930313

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV

    Studying the random variable's moments can help in understanding a number of its distribution characteristics. We'll provide the nth moment of the recommended SPHLD below.

    E(Tn)=0tnδγπtγ1eδtγ(1+eδtγ)2sin(π1+eδtγ)dt. (3.2)

    The following is the series of the sine function:

    sin(t)=j=0(1)jt2j+1(2j+1)!. (3.3)

    Using expansion (3.3) in (3.2) gives

    E(Tn)=j=0(1)jπ2j+2(2j+1)!0δγtn+γ1e2(j+1)δtγ(1+eδtγ)2j+3dt. (3.4)

    The following is the binomial expansion

    (1+y)(a+1)=i=0(1)i(a+ii)yi. (3.5)

    Employing (3.5) in (3.4), we have

    E(Tn)=j,i=0ηi,jδ(n/γ)(2(j+1)+i)(n/γ)+1Γ(nγ+1),

    where ηi,j=(1)j+iπ2j+2(2j+1)!(2j+2+ii), Γ(.) is the gamma function (GaF).

    Furthermore, using moments around the origin, we may compute the nth central moment of T based on the complete moments as follows:

    μn=E[(TE(T))n]=nk=0(1)k(nk)(E(T))k(E(T))nk.

    Next, we get skewness coefficient SK=μ3/μ1.52 and kurtosis coefficient KU=μ4/μ22. They are essential for determining whether the SPHLD is symmetrical or asymmetric. In conclusion, Figure 3 offers 3D plots of mean, variance, skewness, and kurtosis for the SPHLD.

    Figure 3.  The 3D plots of mean, variance, skewness and kurtosis for the SPHLD.

    The nth incomplete moment (IM) of the SPHLD is obtained by using PDF (2.2) as follows:

    ϑn(z)=z0tnδγπtγ1eδtγ(1+eδtγ)2sin(π1+eδtγ)dt.

    Using the expansions (3.2) and (3.4), we have

    ϑn(z)=j,i=0ηi,jz0δγtn+γ1e(2(j+1)+i)δtγdt=j,i=0ηi,jδ(n/γ)((2(j+1)+i))(n/γ)+1Γ(nγ+1,(2(j+1)+i)δzγ),

    where Γ(.,x) is the incomplete GaF. A valuable tool in science, engineering, economics, and demography, the IM is used to estimate Lorenz and Bonferroni curves. These values may be mathematically defined as L(z)=ϑ1(z)/E(T) and B(z)=ϑ1(z)/pE(T). Additionally, it is employed in determining the mean waiting time, say MW(z)=zϑ1(z)/F(z;ζ), and the mean residual life, say MR(z)=[1ϑ1(z)]/S(z;ζ)z.

    The life of a component with random strength T1under random stress T2 is described by the SS model. When the component is subjected to stress greater than its strength, it fails instantly, and when T1>T2, it works properly. Suppose that T1SPHLD(δ1,γ) and T2SPHLD(δ2,γ), then the SS reliability is given by

    β=P(T2<T1)=0δ1γπtγ1eδ1tγ(1+eδ1tγ)2sin(π1+eδ1tγ)cos(π1+eδ2tγ)dt, (3.6)

    since

    cos(t)=j2=0(1)j2t2j22j2!. (3.7)

    Then, using expansions (3.3) and (3.7) in (3.6) provide

    β=j1,j2=0Dj1,j20δ1γtγ1e2(j1+1)δ1tγ(1+eδ1tγ)2j1+3e2δ2j2tγ(1+eδ2tγ)2j2dt, (3.8)

    where Dj1,j2=(1)j1+j2π2j1+2j2+2(2j1+1)!2j2!. Again, using the expansion (3.5) two times in (3.8), we obtain

    β=j1,j2,i1,i2=0Dj1,j2Ki1,i20δ1γtγ1e{δ1[2(j1+1)+i1]+δ2(i2+2j2)}tγdt, (3.9)

    where Ki1,i2=(1)i1+i2(2j1+2+i1i1)(2j21+i2i2). Hence, (3.9) has the following expression

    β=j1,j2,i1,i2=0Dj1,j2Ki1,i2δ1[δ1[2(j1+1)+i1]+δ2(i2+2j2)].

    To estimate the SPHLD parameters, we investigate various classical estimation techniques in this section. The proposed methods are AD, MSALD, MPS, ML, Kolmogorov, LTAD, MSAD, CVM, OLS, MSSD, PC, WLS, MSLD, RTAD, ADSO, and MSSLD. In order to enhance the straightforward nature of the estimation techniques, we have incorporated a more comprehensive explanation of the derivation process for every equation.

    The SPHLD parameters are estimated in this subsection using the ML technique. Let t1,t2,,tn be an n observed sample from PDF (2.2). The log-likelihood function is as below:

    lognlog(δγ)+ni=1(γ1)logti+ni=1δtγi2ni=1log(1+eδtγi)+ni=1log[sin(π1+eδtγ)].

    The log-likelihood function can be maximized to determine the ML estimators (MLEs) ˆδ1 and ˆγ1 of the parameters δ and γ. Alternatively, the following differential equations can be solved about of δ and γ

    logδ=nδ+ni=1tγi2ni=1tγi1+eδtγini=1πtγi(1+eδtγi)2cot(π1+eδtγ)=0, (4.1)

    and

    logγ=nγ+ni=1logti+ni=1δtγilogti2ni=1δtγilogti(1+eδtγi)ni=1cot(π1+eδtγ)δπtγilogti(1+eδtγi)2=0. (4.2)

    Since the aforementioned Eqs (4.1) and (4.2) have no explicit solutions, in order to determine the MLEs of the SPHLD parameters, nonlinear numerical techniques must be used.

    A particular class of minimal distance estimators is the AD estimators. Here, four different estimators for the SPHLD parameters based on the AD approach are determined. These estimators are AD estimators (ADEs), RTAD estimators (RTADEs), ADSO estimators (ADSOEs), and LTAD estimators (LTADEs).

    Suppose that t(1),t(2),,t(n) are the order statistics of a random sample drawn from the SPHLD. Minimizing the following function with respect to the SPHLD parameters, the ADEs ˆδ2 and ˆγ2 of δ and γ are determined

    A1(ζ)=n1nnb=1(2b1){logF(t(b)|ζ)+log(S(t(nb+1)|ζ))},

    where F(.) is the CDF (2.1) and S(.) is the SF (2.3). Solving the following nonlinear equations will also yield the ADEs:

    nb=1(2b1){υζ(t(b)|ζ)F(t(b)|ζ)υζ(t(nb+1)|ζ)S(t(nb+1)|ζ)}=0,ζ=(δ,γ),

    where

    υδ(t(b)|ζ)=F(t(b)|ζ)δ=πtγ(b)eδtγ(b)(1+eδtγ(b))2sin(π1+eδtγ(b)), (4.3)

    and

    υγ(t(b)|ζ)=F(t(b)|ζ)γ=πtγ(b)logt(b)eδtγ(b)(1+eδtγ(b))2sin(π1+eδtγ(b)). (4.4)

    The RTADEs ˆδ3 and ˆγ3 of parameters δ and γ are determined by minimizing the following function with respect to parameters,

    A2(ζ)=n22nb=1F(t(b)|δ,γ)1nn=1(2b1)logS(t(n+1b)|δ,γ)=0, (4.5)

    where F(.) is the CDF (2.1) and S(.) is the SF (2.3). As an alternative to (4.5), the RTADEs can additionally be obtained by solving the following nonlinear equations:

    2nb=1υζ(t(b)|δ,γ)+1nn=1(2b1)S(t(n+1b)|δ,γ)=0,ζ=(δ,γ),

    where, υζ(t(b)|δ,γ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    Next, the ADSOE ˆδ4 and ˆγ4 of parameters δ and γ may be obtained by minimizing the function shown below:

    A3(ζ)=2nb=1logF(t(b)|δ,γ)+1nnb=12b1F(t(b)|δ,γ), (4.6)

    where F(.) is the CDF (2.1). The ADSOEs can also be produced by solving the following nonlinear equations as an alternative to Eq (4.6):

    2nb=1υζ(t(b)|δ,γ)F(t(b)|δ,γ)1nnb=1(2b1)υζ(t(b)|δ,γ)[F(t(b)|δ,γ)]2=0,ζ=(δ,γ),

    where, υζ(t(b)|δ,γ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    The LTADE ˆδ5 and ˆγ5 of parameters δ and γ are determined, respectively, by minimizing the following function:

    A4(ζ)=3n2+2nb=1F(t(b)|ζ)1nnb=1(2b1)logF(t(b)|ζ). (4.7)

    The following nonlinear equations can be quantitatively solved in place of (4.7) to get ˆδ5 and ˆγ5 respectively:

    2nb=1F(t(b)|ζ)υζ(t(b)|δ,γ)1nnb=1(2b1)F(t(b)|ζ)υζ(t(b)|δ,γ)=0,ζ=(δ,γ),

    where, υζ(t(b)|δ,γ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    In place of MLE for estimating the unknown parameters of continuous univariate distributions, [37,38] presented the MPS approach. Ranneby [39] demonstrated that in some circumstances, the MPSE asymptotically has the same properties as the MLE and that the MSP method produces consistent estimates while the ML method does not. Let t(1),t(2),,t(n) be the order statistics of a random sample drawn from the SPHLD. Subsequently, the uniform spacing is established by

    ωb(t;δ,γ)=F(t(b)|δ,γ)F(t(b1)|δ,γ),b=1,2,...,n+1,

    where F(t(0)|δ,γ)=0,F(t(n+1)|δ,γ)=1, and n+1b=1ωb(t;δ,γ)=1. Hence, the following function is maximized with respect to δ and γ to obtain the MPS estimators (MPSEs) of the SPHLD.

    D(ζ)=1n+1n+1b=1log[ωb(t;δ,γ)]. (4.8)

    It is also possible for assessing the MPSEs ˆδ6 and ˆγ6 of parameters δ and γ by solving the following nonlinear equation.

    1n+1n+1b=1υζ(t(b)|ζ)υζ(t(b1)|ζ)ωb(t;ζ)=0,

    where, υζ(t(b)|ζ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    On minimizing the subsequent functions to δ and γ, the OLS estimators (OLSEs) and WLS estimators (WLSEs) of the unknown parameters δ and γ of the SPHLD distribution are obtained

    ls=nb=1(F(t(b)|ζ)bn+1)2ws=nb=1(n+1)2(n+2)b(nb+1)(F(t(b)|ζ)bn+1)2}, (4.9)

    where F(.) is the CDF (2.1). In an equivalent manner to (4.9), the OLSEs ˆδ7 and ˆγ7 and WLSEs ˆδ8 and ˆγ8 of unknown parameters δ and γ may be acquired by working out the following equations, with respect to δ and γ :

    nb=1(F(t(b)|ζ)bn+1)υζ(t(b)|ζ)=0,nb=1(n+1)2(n+2)b(nb+1)(F(t(b)|ζ)bn+1)υζ(t(b)|ζ)=0,

    where F(.) is the CDF (2.1), and υζ(t(b)|δ,γ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    Here, the MSSD estimators (MSSDEs), MSLND estimators (MSLNDEs), MSALD estimators (MSALDEs), MSAD estimators (MSADEs), and MSSLD estimators (MSSLDEs) are obtained.

    The next function is minimized to obtain the MSSDEs ˆδ9 and ˆγ9 of the SPHLD parameters δ and γ :

    V1(ζ)=n+1b=1(ωb(t;ζ)1n+1)2,

    where ωb(t;ζ)=F(t(b)|δ,γ)F(t(b1)|δ,γ). The MSSDEs ˆδ9 and ˆγ9 are generated by solving the following nonlinear equations:

    n+1b=1(ωb(t;ζ)1n+1)[υζ(t(b)|ζ)υζ(t(b1)|ζ)]=0,

    where υζ(.|ζ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    The function that follows is minimized to provide the MSLNDEs ˆδ10 and ˆγ10 of the SPHLD parameters δ and γ

    V2(ζ)=n+1b=1(eωb1n+1(ωb1n+1)1)2. (4.10)

    The following nonlinear equation can be solved as an alternative to (4.10), in order to find the MSLNDEs ˆδ10 and ˆγ10

    n+1b=1(eωb1n+1(ωb1n+1)1)(eωb1n+11)[υζ(t(b)|δ,γ)υζ(t(b1)|δ,γ)]=0,ζ=(δ,γ),

    where, υζ(.|ζ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    Minimizing the function below yields the MSALDEs ˆδ11 and ˆγ11 of δ and γ

    V3(ζ)=n+1b=1|logωb(t;ζ)log1n+1|.

    The MSALDEs ˆδ11 and ˆγ11 are determined by solving the following nonlinear equations:

    n+1b=1logωb(t;ζ)log1n+1|logωb(t;ζ)log1n+1|[υζ(t(b)|ζ)υζ(t(b1)|ζ)]1ωb(t;ζ)=0,

    where υζ(.|ζ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    The MSADEs ˆδ12 and ˆγ12 of the SPHLD parameters δ and γ are produced by minimizing the following function:

    V4(ζ)=n+1b=1|ωb(t;ζ)1n+1|.

    After minimizing the function shown below, the MSADEs ˆδ12 and ˆγ12 are established

    n+1b=1ωb(t;ζ)1n+1|ωb(t;ζ)1n+1|[υζ(t(b)|ζ)υζ(t(b1)|ζ)]=0,

    where υζ(.|ζ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    The MSSLDEs ˆδ13 and ˆγ13 of parameters δ and γ are produced by minimizing the following function:

    V5(ζ)=n+1b=1(logωb(t;ζ)log1n+1)2. (4.11)

    As opposed to using (4.11), the following nonlinear equation must be solved in order to derive the MSSLDEs ˆδ13 and ˆγ13 :

    n+1b=1(logωb(t;ζ)log1n+1)[vζ(t(b)zeta)vζ(t(b1)ζ)]1ωb(t;ζ)=0,

    where υζ(.|ζ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    In comparison to other estimators of the same kind, the CVM estimators (CVMEs) are less biased and fall within the category of minimal distance estimators. Finding the difference between the estimated and empirical CDFs allows one to generate these estimators. The function below can be minimized with regard to δ and γ to get the CVMEs ˆδ14 and ˆγ14 of δ and γ

    C(ζ)=112n+nb=1{F(t(b)|ζ)2b12n}2. (4.12)

    The following nonlinear equation might be solved in place of (4.12), yielding ˆδ14 and ˆγ14

    nb=1{F(t(b)|ζ)2b12n}υζ(t(b)|ζ)=0,

    where υζ(.|δ,γ) and ζ=(δ,γ) are given in (4.3) and (4.4).

    In this subsection, the Kolmogorov estimators (KEs) and the PC estimators (PCEs) of the SPHLD parameters are obtained.

    The estimation of the SPHLD parameters δ and γ is done using the Kolmogorov method. The KEs ˆδ15 and ˆγ15 are obtained after minimizing the following function:

    H(ζ)=Max1bnnb=1[bnF(t(b)|ζ),F(t(b)|ζ)b1n]2,

    where F(.) is the CDF (2.1).

    Next, by equating the sample and population percentile values, the PCEs ˆδ16 and ˆγ16 of the unknown parameters δ and γ are produced. The following function can be minimized in relation to δ and γ to get the ˆδ16 and ˆγ16

    P=nb=1[z(b)F1(pb)]2,pb=bn+1.

    Using a significant quantity of simulated data, this section compares the performance of several estimate methods for estimating the parameters of the proposed model. In our simulation, we used the suggested model quantity function to create random datasets for a variety of sample sizes (n=25,75,150,200,250, and 400). In this part, we will investigate the performance and behavior of our model estimators. Furthermore, we will examine the performance of various estimating strategies using a range of metrics, such as average of bias (|Bias(ζ)|=1LLi=1|ˆζζ|), mean squared errors (MSE=1LLi=1(ˆζζ)2), mean relative errors (MRE=1LLi=1|ˆζζ|/ζ), average absolute difference (Dabs=1nLLi=1nj=1|F(tij|ζ)F(tij|ˆζ)|), maximum absolute difference (Dmax=1LLi=1maxj|F(tij|ζ)F(tij|ˆζ)|), and average squared absolute error (ASAE=1nni=1|ti^ti|tnt1), where the observations ti are in ascending order and ζ=(δ,γ).

    Tables 610 illustrate the results of simulating the specified model parameters using 16 estimating approaches. Figures 4 through 9 visually show the data from Table 6. It is critical to note that all of the parameter estimates for the proposed distribution are quite trustworthy and reasonably near to their real values. As n increases, all anticipated metrics for each scenario under consideration decline. All of the estimating approaches are quite effective at approximating the recommended model parameters. Table 11 shows that the MPS estimate has the lowest overall score, equal to 67.0 for the criteria included in our investigation, followed by the ML estimate as the second-best method for our investigation with a score of 69.0. Table 11 displays the total rankings for all estimating procedures.

    Table 2.  MLEs with their SE of the first data.
    Model Parameter SE Parameter SE Parameter SE
    SPHLD(δ,γ) 3.7870 0.4370 2.2162 0.1836
    EGSHLD(α,β) 7.0611 0.5863 3.3169 0.4593
    EHLD(λ,θ) 4.7771 0.3748 2.7077 0.3918
    PGHLD(α,β,δ) 0.5901 0.0916 2.6059 0.2187 133.3208 3.0465
    KHLD(α,β,θ) 2.5987 0.2161 141.1152 2.1935 0.5731 0.0893
    HLWD(β,θ,δ) 9.2668 0.0013 7.7567 0.0075 0.2865 0.0236
    PHLD(δ,γ) 6.3117 0.7676 2.2754 0.1877

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 3.  Model adequacy and goodness of fit test statistics for the first data.
    Models -2logL AIC BIC CAIC HQIC KS p(KS) CVM p(CVM) AD p(AD)
    SPHLD -50.0009 -46.0009 -40.6552 -45.8877 -43.8338 0.0635 0.7812 0.1027 0.5727 0.8752 0.4295
    EGSHLD -18.5522 -14.5522 -9.2065 -14.439 -12.3851 0.1367 0.0367 0.678 0.0142 3.9479 0.0093
    EHLD -20.661 -16.661 -11.3154 -16.5478 -14.494 0.1291 0.0566 0.6068 0.0213 3.6361 0.0132
    PGHLD -41.7841 -35.7841 -27.7656 -35.5556 -32.5335 0.0868 0.3958 0.2084 0.2519 1.5726 0.1601
    KHLD -42.0805 -36.0805 -28.062 -35.8519 -32.8299 0.0865 0.4001 0.2067 0.255 1.5561 0.1637
    HLWD -50.7479 -44.7479 -36.7294 -44.5193 -41.4973 0.083 0.4532 0.1787 0.3131 1.088 0.3141
    PHLD -48.4568 -44.4568 -39.1112 -44.3436 -42.2898 0.0647 0.7624 0.1082 0.5469 0.9613 0.378

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 4.  MLEs with their SE of the second data.
    Model parameter SE parameter SE parameter SE
    SPHLD(δ,γ) 0.0134 0.0048 1.0754 0.0806
    EGSHLD(α,β) 0.0271 0.0029 1.4176 0.1774
    EHLD(λ,θ) 0.0330 0.0030 1.1827 0.1406
    PGHLD(α,β,δ) 0.0029 6.0E-04 1.3095 0.0959 31.6416 3.0606
    KHLD(α,β,θ) 1.7763 2.0E-04 0.1171 0.0106 0.2100 1.0E-04
    HLWD(β,θ,δ) 3.2E-05 0.0000 2.3012 0.0925 0.5459 0.0382
    PHLD(δ,γ) 0.0188 0.0068 1.1120 0.0833

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 5.  Model adequacy and goodness of fit test statistics for the second data.
    Models -2logL AIC BIC CAIC HQIC KS p(KS) CVM p(CVM) AD p(AD)
    SPHLD 1158.5700 1162.5700 1168.1620 1162.4700 1164.8410 0.0460 0.9603 0.0697 0.7543 0.5285 0.7176
    EGSHLD 1161.6180 1165.6180 1171.2090 1165.7180 1167.8890 0.0848 0.3489 0.0784 0.7023 0.5126 0.7337
    EHLD 1158.7411 1162.7411 1168.4002 1162.5110 1164.9820 0.0569 0.8286 0.0519 0.8652 0.4096 0.8389
    PGHLD 1158.6990 1164.1990 1172.5860 1164.4010 1167.6050 0.0606 0.7658 0.0522 0.8638 0.3987 0.8498
    KHLD 1163.9130 1169.9130 1178.3000 1170.1140 1173.3190 0.1032 0.1521 0.1349 0.4395 0.7670 0.5051
    HLWD 1158.8090 1163.0090 1171.3960 1163.2110 1166.4150 0.0538 0.8752 0.0634 0.7934 0.4578 0.7898
    PHLD 1158.6310 1162.6310 1168.8022 1162.5310 1164.8702 0.0492 0.9311 0.0597 0.8170 0.4685 0.7788

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 6.  Numerical values of simulation measures for δ=2.5,γ=4.0.
    n Est. MLE ADE CVME MPSE OLSE PCE RTADE WLSE LTADE MSADE MSALDE ADSOE KE MSSD MSSLD MSLND
    20 BIAS(ˆδ) 0.50997{10} 0.47624{8} 0.55618{14} 0.4227{1} 0.52808{11} 0.45642{4} 0.48106{9} 0.4697{6} 0.55874{15} 0.47011{7} 0.45026{3} 0.69895{16} 0.4578{5} 0.54062{12} 0.43213{2} 0.55229{13}
    BIAS(ˆγ) 0.65945{6} 0.6582{5} 0.7497{13} 0.62205{2} 0.73052{12} 0.62897{3} 0.70944{10} 0.67628{8} 0.7155{11} 0.65291{4} 0.70363{9} 0.76909{14} 0.55328{1} 0.82507{15} 0.66467{7} 0.87293{16}
    MSE(ˆδ) 0.48274{13} 0.3941{8} 0.58214{15} 0.27484{1} 0.46439{12} 0.33067{4} 0.40226{9} 0.37185{7} 0.53257{14} 0.3537{5} 0.3227{3} 0.7722{16} 0.36868{6} 0.4295{10} 0.31669{2} 0.44799{11}
    MSE(ˆγ) 0.75419{9} 0.70861{5} 0.97653{14} 0.58115{2} 0.87688{12} 0.59901{3} 0.84103{11} 0.73695{7} 0.79691{10} 0.7111{6} 0.73851{8} 0.91542{13} 0.53207{1} 0.99521{15} 0.69597{4} 1.09317{16}
    MRE(ˆδ) 0.20399{10} 0.1905{8} 0.22247{14} 0.16908{1} 0.21123{11} 0.18257{4} 0.19243{9} 0.18788{6} 0.2235{15} 0.18804{7} 0.1801{3} 0.27958{16} 0.18312{5} 0.21625{12} 0.17285{2} 0.22092{13}
    MRE(ˆγ) 0.16486{6} 0.16455{5} 0.18742{13} 0.15551{2} 0.18263{12} 0.15724{3} 0.17736{10} 0.16907{8} 0.17887{11} 0.16323{4} 0.17591{9} 0.19227{14} 0.13832{1} 0.20627{15} 0.16617{7} 0.21823{16}
    Dabs 0.05542{1} 0.05852{6} 0.05875{7} 0.05789{4} 0.06077{10} 0.05774{3} 0.05704{2} 0.05827{5} 0.05946{9} 0.06363{13} 0.06702{14} 0.06358{12} 0.05891{8} 0.06948{15} 0.06084{11} 0.0712{16}
    Dmax 0.09015{1} 0.09333{7} 0.09632{9} 0.0904{2} 0.09725{11} 0.09107{3} 0.09261{5} 0.0929{6} 0.09717{10} 0.10099{12} 0.10555{13} 0.10614{14} 0.09162{4} 0.1109{15} 0.09595{8} 0.11392{16}
    ASAE 0.04585{1} 0.04191{7} 0.04337{9} 0.04308{2} 0.04118{11} 0.04172{3} 0.04508{5} 0.04062{6} 0.04319{10} 0.05482{12} 0.05271{13} 0.05203{14} 0.04583{4} 0.05973{15} 0.04937{8} 0.06062{16}
    Ranks 66{7} 56{6} 106{13} 20{1} 93{11} 30{2} 73{9} 54{4.5} 101{12} 72{8} 75{10} 127{15} 40{3} 124{14} 54{4.5} 133{16}
    70 BIAS(ˆδ) 0.23302{3} 0.2412{4} 0.30468{12} 0.22791{1} 0.27786{11} 0.23246{2} 0.26005{8} 0.25407{7} 0.32622{15} 0.27753{10} 0.24555{5} 0.49886{16} 0.26772{9} 0.31504{14} 0.24582{6} 0.30999{13}
    BIAS(ˆγ) 0.3245{1} 0.32947{2} 0.39565{12} 0.33268{3} 0.38705{11} 0.34282{5} 0.37162{7} 0.36078{6} 0.40446{13} 0.3758{8} 0.38459{10} 0.54412{16} 0.33343{4} 0.45321{14} 0.38433{9} 0.4608{15}
    MSE(ˆδ) 0.09308{3} 0.09963{5} 0.17211{14} 0.08165{1} 0.131{11} 0.0835{2} 0.12498{8} 0.11594{7} 0.19003{15} 0.12754{10} 0.09977{6} 0.41958{16} 0.12736{9} 0.15069{13} 0.09772{4} 0.14683{12}
    MSE(ˆγ) 0.17324{2} 0.17331{3} 0.25132{12} 0.16753{1} 0.23172{10} 0.18154{4} 0.23363{11} 0.20815{6} 0.26128{13} 0.22809{9} 0.22537{7} 0.4488{16} 0.20041{5} 0.32895{15} 0.22666{8} 0.32661{14}
    MRE(ˆδ) 0.09321{3} 0.09648{4} 0.12187{12} 0.09117{1} 0.11114{11} 0.09299{2} 0.10402{8} 0.10163{7} 0.13049{15} 0.11101{10} 0.09822{5} 0.19954{16} 0.10709{9} 0.12602{14} 0.09833{6} 0.12399{13}
    MRE(ˆγ) 0.08113{1} 0.08237{2} 0.09891{12} 0.08317{3} 0.09676{11} 0.0857{5} 0.0929{7} 0.0902{6} 0.10112{13} 0.09395{8} 0.09615{10} 0.13603{16} 0.08336{4} 0.1133{14} 0.09608{9} 0.1152{15}
    Dabs 0.0291{1} 0.03155{7} 0.03136{6} 0.03121{5} 0.03271{10} 0.03079{2} 0.03097{3} 0.03118{4} 0.03217{9} 0.03687{13} 0.0343{11} 0.039{14} 0.03186{8} 0.03963{15} 0.03489{12} 0.03977{16}
    Dmax 0.04706{1} 0.05079{5} 0.05236{8} 0.04993{3} 0.05362{9} 0.04926{2} 0.05056{4} 0.05084{6} 0.05385{10} 0.05874{13} 0.0553{11} 0.06884{16} 0.05146{7} 0.06406{14} 0.05617{12} 0.0649{15}
    ASAE 0.02068{1} 0.0194{5} 0.02022{8} 0.02038{3} 0.0197{9} 0.01966{2} 0.02055{4} 0.01914{6} 0.02024{10} 0.0263{13} 0.0254{11} 0.02805{16} 0.02126{7} 0.02941{14} 0.02373{12} 0.02958{15}
    Ranks 24{1} 34{4} 93{11} 25{2} 88{10} 27{3} 64{6} 50{5} 109{13} 94{12} 77{8.5} 140{16} 65{7} 128{14} 77{8.5} 129{15}
    150 BIAS(ˆδ) 0.15673{2} 0.15991{3} 0.18883{10} 0.15145{1} 0.18886{11} 0.16135{4} 0.1763{8} 0.16792{6} 0.22306{15} 0.19224{12} 0.17614{7} 0.37121{16} 0.17811{9} 0.21099{13} 0.16783{5} 0.21401{14}
    BIAS(ˆγ) 0.21048{1} 0.23683{4} 0.26398{12} 0.22694{2} 0.25585{10} 0.23069{3} 0.25039{8} 0.24322{6} 0.28777{13} 0.26282{11} 0.25477{9} 0.39249{16} 0.23897{5} 0.32228{15} 0.24795{7} 0.31651{14}
    MSE(ˆδ) 0.03876{2} 0.0421{4} 0.05973{11} 0.03526{1} 0.06179{12} 0.03983{3} 0.05052{8} 0.04654{5} 0.0843{15} 0.05917{10} 0.04776{7} 0.22463{16} 0.05493{9} 0.07{13} 0.04684{6} 0.07287{14}
    MSE(ˆγ) 0.07143{1} 0.08939{4} 0.10989{11} 0.07985{2} 0.10559{10} 0.08356{3} 0.10142{8} 0.09184{5} 0.1303{13} 0.11125{12} 0.10348{9} 0.24262{16} 0.0989{7} 0.15864{15} 0.09643{6} 0.15711{14}
    MRE(ˆδ) 0.06269{2} 0.06396{3} 0.07553{10} 0.06058{1} 0.07554{11} 0.06454{4} 0.07052{8} 0.06717{6} 0.08923{15} 0.07689{12} 0.07046{7} 0.14849{16} 0.07124{9} 0.0844{13} 0.06713{5} 0.0856{14}
    MRE(ˆγ) 0.05262{1} 0.05921{4} 0.066{12} 0.05674{2} 0.06396{10} 0.05767{3} 0.0626{8} 0.06081{6} 0.07194{13} 0.06571{11} 0.06369{9} 0.09812{16} 0.05974{5} 0.08057{15} 0.06199{7} 0.07913{14}
    Dabs 0.02054{1} 0.02072{2} 0.02154{6.5} 0.0209{3} 0.02214{8} 0.02154{6.5} 0.0215{5} 0.02124{4} 0.02222{10} 0.02553{13} 0.02417{12} 0.02878{15} 0.02217{9} 0.029{16} 0.02327{11} 0.02835{14}
    Dmax 0.03296{1} 0.03367{3} 0.03572{7} 0.03363{2} 0.03616{9} 0.03467{5} 0.03506{6} 0.03443{4} 0.03725{10} 0.04088{13} 0.03877{12} 0.0513{16} 0.03581{8} 0.04664{15} 0.03742{11} 0.04585{14}
    ASAE 0.01285{1} 0.0121{3} 0.01253{7} 0.01291{2} 0.0126{9} 0.0126{5} 0.01309{6} 0.01218{4} 0.01276{10} 0.01719{13} 0.01618{12} 0.01927{16} 0.0134{8} 0.01885{15} 0.01518{11} 0.01927{14}
    Ranks 18{1} 28{3} 82.5{9} 22{2} 86{11} 35.5{4} 68{6} 44{5} 110{13} 107{12} 84{10} 143{16} 71{8} 129{15} 69{7} 127{14}
    200 BIAS(ˆδ) 0.13265{2} 0.13595{3} 0.1673{11} 0.13118{1} 0.16857{12} 0.13838{5} 0.13802{4} 0.14025{6} 0.18959{15} 0.16663{10} 0.15183{8} 0.33625{16} 0.16201{9} 0.18672{14} 0.14916{7} 0.1847{13}
    BIAS(ˆγ) 0.1819{1} 0.2009{4} 0.23223{11} 0.19663{2} 0.23062{10} 0.19721{3} 0.21404{7} 0.20405{5} 0.24252{13} 0.23595{12} 0.22556{9} 0.35139{16} 0.21768{8} 0.26822{14} 0.21092{6} 0.28227{15}
    MSE(ˆδ) 0.02876{2} 0.03111{5} 0.04706{12} 0.02608{1} 0.04487{11} 0.02986{3} 0.02999{4} 0.03198{6} 0.05815{15} 0.04388{9} 0.03648{8} 0.17779{16} 0.04457{10} 0.0543{14} 0.03468{7} 0.05337{13}
    MSE(ˆγ) 0.05319{1} 0.06643{5} 0.0866{11} 0.05773{2} 0.08181{9} 0.06042{3} 0.07294{7} 0.0649{4} 0.09347{13} 0.0891{12} 0.07835{8} 0.18831{16} 0.08335{10} 0.10843{14} 0.07018{6} 0.12237{15}
    MRE(ˆδ) 0.05306{2} 0.05438{3} 0.06692{11} 0.05247{1} 0.06743{12} 0.05535{5} 0.05521{4} 0.0561{6} 0.07583{15} 0.06665{10} 0.06073{8} 0.1345{16} 0.0648{9} 0.07469{14} 0.05966{7} 0.07388{13}
    MRE(ˆγ) 0.04548{1} 0.05022{4} 0.05806{11} 0.04916{2} 0.05765{10} 0.0493{3} 0.05351{7} 0.05101{5} 0.06063{13} 0.05899{12} 0.05639{9} 0.08785{16} 0.05442{8} 0.06705{14} 0.05273{6} 0.07057{15}
    Dabs 0.01756{1} 0.01875{6} 0.01966{9} 0.01806{2} 0.01886{7} 0.01851{3} 0.01865{5} 0.01857{4} 0.02{10} 0.02234{13} 0.02071{12} 0.02553{16} 0.01939{8} 0.02374{14} 0.02001{11} 0.02467{15}
    Dmax 0.02827{1} 0.03015{5} 0.03226{10} 0.02899{2} 0.03112{7} 0.02971{3} 0.03023{6} 0.02997{4} 0.03328{11} 0.03587{13} 0.03331{12} 0.04625{16} 0.03149{8} 0.03869{14} 0.03217{9} 0.03998{15}
    ASAE 0.01079{1} 0.01033{5} 0.01064{10} 0.01096{2} 0.01058{7} 0.0105{3} 0.01128{6} 0.01037{4} 0.01071{11} 0.01466{13} 0.0135{12} 0.01705{16} 0.01127{8} 0.01565{14} 0.01282{9} 0.01625{15}
    Ranks 18{1} 36{4} 91{11} 21{2} 82{9} 31{3} 54{6} 42{5} 111{13} 104{12} 86{10} 144{16} 79{8} 126{14} 70{7} 129{15}
    300 BIAS(ˆδ) 0.10974{2} 0.11844{5} 0.13179{9} 0.10665{1} 0.13783{12} 0.1132{3} 0.11493{4} 0.11974{6} 0.14628{13} 0.13581{11} 0.12478{8} 0.2783{16} 0.1341{10} 0.15588{15} 0.12086{7} 0.14797{14}
    BIAS(ˆγ) 0.14742{1} 0.16142{3} 0.18156{10} 0.16198{4} 0.1938{12} 0.1533{2} 0.16496{5} 0.17827{7} 0.1921{11} 0.19653{13} 0.17965{8} 0.28618{16} 0.18104{9} 0.22094{15} 0.17758{6} 0.2143{14}
    MSE(ˆδ) 0.01875{2} 0.02203{5} 0.02817{9} 0.01818{1} 0.03043{12} 0.02021{3} 0.02064{4} 0.02295{7} 0.03499{13} 0.02881{11} 0.02412{8} 0.12932{16} 0.0286{10} 0.03896{15} 0.02229{6} 0.03584{14}
    MSE(ˆγ) 0.03488{1} 0.04131{4} 0.05192{9} 0.04036{3} 0.05898{12} 0.03722{2} 0.04372{5} 0.04954{7} 0.05812{11} 0.06262{13} 0.05007{8} 0.13548{16} 0.05346{10} 0.07594{15} 0.04802{6} 0.07302{14}
    MRE(ˆδ) 0.0439{2} 0.04737{5} 0.05272{9} 0.04266{1} 0.05513{12} 0.04528{3} 0.04597{4} 0.0479{6} 0.05851{13} 0.05433{11} 0.04991{8} 0.11132{16} 0.05364{10} 0.06235{15} 0.04834{7} 0.05919{14}
    MRE(ˆγ) 0.03685{1} 0.04036{3} 0.04539{10} 0.04049{4} 0.04845{12} 0.03832{2} 0.04124{5} 0.04457{7} 0.04802{11} 0.04913{13} 0.04491{8} 0.07155{16} 0.04526{9} 0.05524{15} 0.04439{6} 0.05357{14}
    Dabs 0.01362{1} 0.01495{6} 0.01533{8} 0.01478{5} 0.01539{9} 0.01426{2} 0.01476{4} 0.01472{3} 0.01529{7} 0.01826{13} 0.01734{12} 0.02195{16} 0.01583{10} 0.0199{14} 0.0161{11} 0.02005{15}
    Dmax 0.02211{1} 0.02424{6} 0.02529{7} 0.02366{3} 0.02549{8} 0.02312{2} 0.02388{4} 0.02416{5} 0.0255{9} 0.02944{13} 0.02777{12} 0.03943{16} 0.0259{10} 0.03232{15} 0.02613{11} 0.0323{14}
    ASAE 0.00851{1} 0.00811{6} 0.00842{7} 0.00842{3} 0.00824{8} 0.00839{2} 0.00871{4} 0.00814{5} 0.00844{9} 0.01156{13} 0.0109{12} 0.01371{16} 0.00883{10} 0.01255{15} 0.01019{11} 0.01271{14}
    Ranks 19{1} 38{4} 77{8} 27{3} 92{11} 23{2} 44{5} 50{6} 95{12} 111{13} 84{9} 144{16} 88{10} 133{15} 71{7} 128{14}
    450 BIAS(ˆδ) 0.08895{2} 0.09072{3} 0.11445{12} 0.08675{1} 0.10738{10} 0.09073{4} 0.09415{5} 0.0949{6} 0.12204{13} 0.11394{11} 0.10417{8} 0.22716{16} 0.10475{9} 0.12807{15} 0.09963{7} 0.12233{14}
    BIAS(ˆγ) 0.1248{1} 0.13118{4} 0.15604{12} 0.12656{2} 0.15209{10} 0.13038{3} 0.15018{9} 0.13814{5} 0.15294{11} 0.16044{13} 0.14765{8} 0.24681{16} 0.14338{6} 0.17673{15} 0.14537{7} 0.17526{14}
    MSE(ˆδ) 0.01257{2} 0.01291{4} 0.02057{11} 0.01176{1} 0.01849{10} 0.01269{3} 0.01407{5} 0.01462{6} 0.02287{13} 0.02088{12} 0.01688{8} 0.08455{16} 0.0176{9} 0.02511{15} 0.01571{7} 0.02359{14}
    MSE(ˆγ) 0.0249{1} 0.02715{4} 0.03896{12} 0.02562{2} 0.03687{10} 0.02638{3} 0.03486{9} 0.03042{5} 0.03691{11} 0.04153{13} 0.03326{7} 0.09873{16} 0.03448{8} 0.04877{15} 0.03238{6} 0.04832{14}
    MRE(ˆδ) 0.03558{2} 0.03629{3.5} 0.04578{12} 0.0347{1} 0.04295{10} 0.03629{3.5} 0.03766{5} 0.03796{6} 0.04881{13} 0.04558{11} 0.04167{8} 0.09086{16} 0.0419{9} 0.05123{15} 0.03985{7} 0.04893{14}
    MRE(ˆγ) 0.0312{1} 0.0328{4} 0.03901{12} 0.03164 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03802 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0326 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03755 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03453 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03823 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04011 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03691 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0617 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03584 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04418 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03634 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04381 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01206 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0118 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01283 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01195 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01252 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0122 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01285 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01236 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01279 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0151 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01376 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01756 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01274 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01662 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01351 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01591 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.0194 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01913 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02112 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01918 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02062 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01963 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0208 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02007 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02128 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02436 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02228 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03163 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02078 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02684 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02176 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02572 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.0068 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00657 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00666 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0068 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00659 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00666 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00675 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00645 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00672 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00925 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00841 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01085 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00715 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01005 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00797 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01017 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 24 ^{\{ 2 \}} 26.5 ^{\{ 3 \}} 94 ^{\{ 11 \}} 21 ^{\{ 1 \}} 75 ^{\{ 9 \}} 31.5 ^{\{ 4 \}} 67 ^{\{ 6 \}} 44 ^{\{ 5 \}} 96 ^{\{ 12 \}} 112 ^{\{ 13 \}} 83 ^{\{ 10 \}} 144 ^{\{ 16 \}} 71 ^{\{ 7 \}} 134 ^{\{ 15 \}} 74 ^{\{ 8 \}} 127 ^{\{ 14 \}}

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 7.  Numerical values of simulation measures for \delta = 0.8, \gamma = 0.3 .
    n Est. MLE ADE CVME MPSE OLSE PCE RTADE WLSE LTADE MSADE MSALDE ADSOE KE MSSD MSSLD MSLND
    20 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.13569 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.13611 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.14304 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.11914 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.13443 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.23732 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.13881 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.13078 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.145 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.14272 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.13867 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.15516 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.14722 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.13911 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.13978 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.13755 ^{\{ 6 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04852 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04836 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06184 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04882 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05532 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.10105 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05227 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05221 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05666 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0622 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05323 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0738 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05983 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06465 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04883 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06543 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.02924 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03072 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 0.03339 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02293 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02941 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08556 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03083 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02791 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03622 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03338 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03296 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04423 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0359 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03072 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 0.03037 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03074 ^{\{ 8 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00409 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0038 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00673 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00366 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00511 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01506 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00465 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00459 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00576 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00621 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00433 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00882 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00612 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00618 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00373 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00633 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.16961 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.17014 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.17881 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.14892 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.16804 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.29665 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.17352 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.16347 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.18125 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.1784 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.17334 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.19395 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.18402 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.17389 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.17473 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.17193 ^{\{ 6 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.16174 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.1612 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.20613 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.16273 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.18441 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.33685 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.17424 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.17403 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.18886 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.20735 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.17743 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.24601 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.19943 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.21551 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.16277 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.21812 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.05531 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05792 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06031 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05725 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06112 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10551 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05954 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05815 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06079 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06665 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06419 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06793 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06068 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07137 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06132 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.07046 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.09073 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09264 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.10036 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0902 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.09881 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.17373 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.09574 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.09359 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.1012 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10726 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.10174 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.11822 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.10136 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.11505 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.09648 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.11428 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    ASAE 0.04603 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04811 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05374 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04434 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06565 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0267 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0424 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04964 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08063 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04583 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04342 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.42444 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05812 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0862 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05103 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.08934 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    \sum Ranks 28 ^{\{ 2 \}} 34.5 ^{\{ 3 \}} 96 ^{\{ 9 \}} 17 ^{\{ 1 \}} 62 ^{\{ 7 \}} 129 ^{\{ 15 \}} 56 ^{\{ 5 \}} 38 ^{\{ 4 \}} 97 ^{\{ 10 \}} 98 ^{\{ 11 \}} 68 ^{\{ 8 \}} 134 ^{\{ 16 \}} 99 ^{\{ 12 \}} 104.5 ^{\{ 14 \}} 60 ^{\{ 6 \}} 103 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    70 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.07296 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06964 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.07359 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07124 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07313 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.18982 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.07141 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06974 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.07362 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0874 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0797 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08887 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.07713 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.08667 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0757 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.08745 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.02459 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02612 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03127 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02602 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0292 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0696 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02598 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02544 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02942 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03295 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02869 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04133 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03019 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03481 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02684 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03435 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00838 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00771 ^{\{ 1.5 \}} 0.00865 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00801 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0085 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0611 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00817 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00771 ^{\{ 1.5 \}} 0.00869 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01225 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01009 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01295 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00958 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01229 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00905 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01253 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00099 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00108 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00163 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00104 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00135 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00721 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00111 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00103 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00144 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00171 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00125 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00265 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00151 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00187 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00114 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0018 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.09119 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.08705 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.09199 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08905 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.09141 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.23728 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.08926 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08718 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09203 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.10925 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09963 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.11109 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.09642 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.10834 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.09462 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10931 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.08196 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.08707 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.10422 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08674 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09732 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.232 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.08659 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0848 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09806 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10984 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.09562 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.13777 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.10063 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.11604 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.08946 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.1145 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.03066 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03051 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0325 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03188 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03278 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07892 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03045 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03058 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03232 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03856 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03556 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04174 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0333 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04018 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03322 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04055 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.04975 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.04967 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05402 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05105 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05348 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.12657 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04963 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04975 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.05403 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06225 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0567 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07376 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0551 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06547 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05338 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06543 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    ASAE 0.0162 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.01797 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02094 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01643 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02195 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01337 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01615 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01862 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.02546 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01928 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01803 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.09751 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02182 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02609 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01813 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02645 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    \sum Ranks 28.5 ^{\{ 4 \}} 26.5 ^{\{ 2 \}} 79 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 34 ^{\{ 5 \}} 69 ^{\{ 7 \}} 129 ^{\{ 15 \}} 27 ^{\{ 3 \}} 26 ^{\{ 1 \}} 79 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 107 ^{\{ 12 \}} 82 ^{\{ 10 \}} 136 ^{\{ 16 \}} 91 ^{\{ 11 \}} 120 ^{\{ 13 \}} 67 ^{\{ 6 \}} 123 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    150 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.04684 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04829 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04887 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 0.04806 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04987 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.17968 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04887 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 0.04975 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05064 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05928 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05586 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06197 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05002 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06334 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05037 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06384 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.01666 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01759 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02009 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01747 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02006 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06159 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01832 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0185 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02003 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0217 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0192 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02988 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02063 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02394 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01753 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02409 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00343 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00367 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00382 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00363 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00389 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05875 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00372 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00387 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00409 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00543 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00503 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0063 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00394 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00615 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00404 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00634 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00045 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00048 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00064 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00046 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00062 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.00575 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00054 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.00054 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.00062 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.00073 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00056 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0014 ^{\{ 15 \}} 7e-04 ^{\{ 11 \}} 9e-04 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00047 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00088 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.05855 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06037 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06108 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 0.06008 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06234 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.2246 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.06108 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 0.06219 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0633 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0741 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06982 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07746 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06253 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07917 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.06296 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0798 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.05553 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05865 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06697 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05823 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06687 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.2053 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.06107 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06166 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06675 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07234 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06399 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09959 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06876 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07981 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05845 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.08029 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.02014 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02095 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02155 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02132 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02237 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07261 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02134 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02169 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02256 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02615 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02437 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02995 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02244 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0284 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02199 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02844 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.03246 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03388 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03559 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03417 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03664 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.11597 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03474 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03524 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0373 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04235 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0391 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05332 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03699 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04607 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03549 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04632 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00893 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01018 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01121 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00853 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01162 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00883 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.009 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00981 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01321 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01058 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00981 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03661 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01211 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01329 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00993 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01331 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 11 ^{\{ 1 \}} 33 ^{\{ 3 \}} 66 ^{\{ 7 \}} 19 ^{\{ 2 \}} 74.5 ^{\{ 8 \}} 128 ^{\{ 14.5 \}} 40.5 ^{\{ 4 \}} 52.5 ^{\{ 5 \}} 87.5 ^{\{ 10 \}} 104 ^{\{ 12 \}} 81 ^{\{ 9 \}} 129 ^{\{ 16 \}} 91 ^{\{ 11 \}} 123 ^{\{ 13 \}} 56 ^{\{ 6 \}} 128 ^{\{ 14.5 \}}
    200 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.04341 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03894 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04242 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04287 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04155 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.16861 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04223 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04141 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0428 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0525 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04708 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05372 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04369 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05334 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04767 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05288 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.01466 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0152 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01737 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01482 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01744 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05522 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01611 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01546 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01751 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.019 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01669 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.026 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01733 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02049 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01646 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02067 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00301 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00239 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00281 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0029 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00279 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05237 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00282 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00268 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00291 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00451 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00352 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00452 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00307 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00453 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00356 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00449 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00035 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00038 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00047 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00034 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00048 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00465 ^{\{ 16 \}} 4e-04 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00039 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00049 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 0.00056 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00044 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00111 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00049 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 0.00064 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00042 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00067 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.05427 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04867 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05302 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05358 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05194 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.21077 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05278 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05176 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05349 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06562 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05885 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06715 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05462 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06668 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05959 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06611 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04887 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05067 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05789 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04941 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05813 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.18407 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05369 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05154 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05836 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06333 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05564 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08668 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05776 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0683 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05488 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0689 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01861 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01734 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01893 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01868 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0188 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06765 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01843 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01809 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01907 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02302 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02074 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02596 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01938 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0239 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02062 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02397 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.02971 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02823 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03122 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02995 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03106 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.10653 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02997 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02958 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0319 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03705 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03334 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04661 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03204 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03867 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03292 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03921 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00707 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00822 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00916 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00728 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00916 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00736 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00708 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00804 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01016 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00844 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00794 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02823 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0094 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01004 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00783 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0105 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 36 ^{\{ 3 \}} 22 ^{\{ 1 \}} 64 ^{\{ 7 \}} 37 ^{\{ 4 \}} 59 ^{\{ 6 \}} 131 ^{\{ 15 \}} 49 ^{\{ 5 \}} 29 ^{\{ 2 \}} 80.5 ^{\{ 10 \}} 105 ^{\{ 12 \}} 78 ^{\{ 9 \}} 134 ^{\{ 16 \}} 82.5 ^{\{ 11 \}} 120 ^{\{ 13 \}} 75 ^{\{ 8 \}} 122 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    300 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.03359 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03426 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03522 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03414 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0339 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.15982 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03524 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03559 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03562 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04236 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03961 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04313 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03677 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04397 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03893 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04451 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.01137 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01228 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01405 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01219 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01354 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05028 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01315 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01242 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01412 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01532 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01366 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02121 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01461 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01687 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01337 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01621 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00174 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00183 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00192 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00187 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0018 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04814 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00198 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00197 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00199 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00292 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00245 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.003 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00214 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00314 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00231 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00318 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00021 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00023 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 0.00032 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 0.00023 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 0.00029 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00397 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00027 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00025 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00032 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 0.00036 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00028 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 0.00074 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00033 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00045 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00028 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 0.00043 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.04199 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04282 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04403 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04268 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04238 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.19977 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04404 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04449 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04453 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05295 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04952 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05391 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04597 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05496 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04866 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05564 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.0379 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04092 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04685 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04065 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04512 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.16759 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04382 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04141 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04707 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05107 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04554 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0707 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0487 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05622 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04456 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05404 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01428 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01493 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01562 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.015 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01523 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06329 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01533 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01542 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01592 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01858 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01711 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02105 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01634 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0196 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01678 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01968 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.0231 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02413 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02571 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02402 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02497 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.09926 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0248 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02495 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02655 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02992 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02754 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03749 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02695 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03206 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02701 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0319 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    ASAE 0.00503 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00586 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00626 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0051 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00667 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00572 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00531 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00569 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00725 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00629 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0057 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01823 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00683 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00742 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00555 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00735 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    \sum Ranks 9 ^{\{ 1 \}} 32.5 ^{\{ 3 \}} 65.5 ^{\{ 7 \}} 23.5 ^{\{ 2 \}} 49 ^{\{ 6 \}} 135 ^{\{ 16 \}} 46 ^{\{ 4 \}} 48 ^{\{ 5 \}} 82.5 ^{\{ 9 \}} 106 ^{\{ 12 \}} 83.5 ^{\{ 10 \}} 130 ^{\{ 15 \}} 90 ^{\{ 11 \}} 126 ^{\{ 14 \}} 72.5 ^{\{ 8 \}} 125 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    450 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.02849 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02771 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02723 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0272 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02835 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.14718 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02885 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02788 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02901 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03489 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03154 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03737 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02814 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03623 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03103 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.037 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00965 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00997 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01198 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0093 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01114 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04448 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01054 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01018 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01105 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01207 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01051 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01806 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01153 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01314 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01081 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01315 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00125 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.00119 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 0.00119 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 0.00117 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00127 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04381 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00128 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00125 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.00132 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00193 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0016 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0022 ^{\{ 14.5 \}} 0.00123 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00207 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00151 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0022 ^{\{ 14.5 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00015 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00016 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.00022 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 0.00013 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00019 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.00326 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00018 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00016 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.00019 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.00023 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00018 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00052 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00022 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 0.00027 ^{\{ 13.5 \}} 0.00018 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00027 ^{\{ 13.5 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.03561 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03463 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03404 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.034 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03543 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.18398 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03606 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03485 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03627 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04361 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03943 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04671 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03518 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04529 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03879 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04626 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03216 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03322 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03995 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03099 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03715 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.14827 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03512 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03395 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03684 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04024 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03502 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0602 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03843 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04381 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03602 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04383 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01217 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.01203 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01254 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.0118 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01259 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05777 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01254 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.01217 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.01282 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01499 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01365 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0179 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01262 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01585 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01354 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01633 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.01954 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01966 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02084 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01902 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0206 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.09011 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02035 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0197 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02134 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02413 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02191 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03217 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02103 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02567 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02172 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02642 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00367 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00414 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00475 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00367 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0047 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00441 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00389 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00421 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00514 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00441 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00441 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01141 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00498 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00517 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0041 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00505 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 33 ^{\{ 3 \}} 28 ^{\{ 2 \}} 62.5 ^{\{ 6 \}} 9 ^{\{ 1 \}} 68.5 ^{\{ 7 \}} 137 ^{\{ 16 \}} 55.5 ^{\{ 5 \}} 38.5 ^{\{ 4 \}} 83.5 ^{\{ 11 \}} 104 ^{\{ 12 \}} 78 ^{\{ 10 \}} 135.5 ^{\{ 15 \}} 72.5 ^{\{ 8 \}} 119.5 ^{\{ 13 \}} 74 ^{\{ 9 \}} 125 ^{\{ 14 \}}

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 8.  Numerical values of simulation measures for \delta = 0.4, \gamma = 1.5 .
    n Est. MLE ADE CVME MPSE OLSE PCE RTADE WLSE LTADE MSADE MSALDE ADSOE KE MSSD MSSLD MSLND
    20 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.09101 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09313 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.09815 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.09237 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09432 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.09341 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0981 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.09231 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.09406 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.10135 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.10156 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.09488 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0905 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.10724 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.1011 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.10679 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.24286 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.23531 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.29982 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.24475 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.2741 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.24374 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.26941 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.26062 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.30261 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.24144 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.2443 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.34346 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.19995 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.31841 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.23577 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.32015 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.01264 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01384 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01474 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01362 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01402 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01346 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01544 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0135 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01369 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01643 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0167 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01406 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01276 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01786 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01573 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01802 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.10211 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.09051 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.15669 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.09054 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.12578 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.09169 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.1259 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.12059 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.15608 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.10091 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09303 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.19169 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.07721 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.15596 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0862 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.15691 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.22752 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.23283 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.24537 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.23092 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.2358 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.23353 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.24524 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.23077 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.23515 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.25338 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.2539 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.23721 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.22626 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.2681 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.25275 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.26697 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.1619 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.15687 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.19988 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.16317 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.18273 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.16249 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.17961 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.17375 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.20174 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.16096 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.16286 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.22897 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.1333 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.21227 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.15718 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.21343 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.05406 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05653 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.059 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05707 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0592 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05783 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05875 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0581 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06031 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06505 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06303 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06891 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05967 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.07115 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.06078 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07068 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{max} 0.08883 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.09041 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.09875 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.09 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09621 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.09085 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09549 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09422 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.10075 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.10336 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09961 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.1194 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.09486 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.11513 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.096 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.11422 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.04552 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04129 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04352 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0421 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04259 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04025 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04201 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04014 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04631 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05495 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05154 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06866 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04793 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06063 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.049 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06158 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 33 ^{\{ 3 \}} 32 ^{\{ 1.5 \}} 94 ^{\{ 12 \}} 43 ^{\{ 5 \}} 79 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 42 ^{\{ 4 \}} 79 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 48 ^{\{ 6 \}} 90 ^{\{ 10 \}} 93 ^{\{ 11 \}} 97 ^{\{ 13 \}} 121 ^{\{ 14 \}} 32 ^{\{ 1.5 \}} 132 ^{\{ 15 \}} 74 ^{\{ 7 \}} 135 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    70 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.0481 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05165 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05356 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05241 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05152 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05205 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05239 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05128 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05271 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06183 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05814 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05235 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04805 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06292 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05444 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06617 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.11542 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.1306 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.15145 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.13011 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.1467 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.13022 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.13686 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.12861 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.15339 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.13907 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.13901 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.21446 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.11885 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.17721 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.12857 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.17739 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00371 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00425 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00459 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0043 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00415 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00444 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00423 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0041 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00442 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00627 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00532 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00426 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00378 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00636 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00471 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00704 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.02207 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02746 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03672 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02552 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03476 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02672 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02954 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02659 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03801 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03324 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02999 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.07196 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02561 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04841 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02515 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04931 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.12025 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.12913 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.13391 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.13103 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.1288 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.13013 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.13097 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.1282 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.13177 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.15459 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.14535 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.13087 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.12012 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.1573 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.1361 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.16544 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.07695 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.08707 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.10097 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.08674 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0978 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08681 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.09124 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.08574 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.10226 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09271 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.09267 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.14297 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.07923 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.11814 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.08571 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.11826 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.029 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03098 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03229 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03129 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03173 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03149 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03107 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03048 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03321 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03821 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03553 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04234 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03159 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03854 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03314 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04108 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{max} 0.04673 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05004 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05334 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05006 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05236 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05032 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05057 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04942 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05539 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06103 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05694 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.07498 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05124 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06295 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0533 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06672 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    ASAE 0.02027 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0192 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0198 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02014 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01985 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01955 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01938 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01906 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02191 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02726 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02532 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03829 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02211 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02947 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0234 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03035 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    \sum Ranks 18 ^{\{ 1 \}} 45 ^{\{ 4 \}} 93 ^{\{ 10 \}} 55 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 67 ^{\{ 8 \}} 55 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 58 ^{\{ 7 \}} 27 ^{\{ 2 \}} 99 ^{\{ 11 \}} 111 ^{\{ 13 \}} 102 ^{\{ 12 \}} 117 ^{\{ 14 \}} 36 ^{\{ 3 \}} 129 ^{\{ 15 \}} 74 ^{\{ 9 \}} 138 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    150 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.03328 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0353 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0374 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03498 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03719 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03551 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03615 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0356 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03506 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04183 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03989 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0349 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03389 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04561 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03987 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04643 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.08222 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08757 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.10185 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0854 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09794 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.08475 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.09216 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08967 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.10362 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09947 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.09497 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.14629 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.08125 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.11894 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.09383 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.11833 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00173 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00199 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00217 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00191 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.00212 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00195 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00203 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00198 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00194 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00287 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00253 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00191 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.00185 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00328 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0025 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0034 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.01055 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01222 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01657 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01115 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01489 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0111 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01324 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01255 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01754 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01697 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01365 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03483 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01219 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02212 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0138 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02208 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.0832 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.08825 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.09351 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08745 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09298 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.08878 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09037 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.08899 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.08765 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.10457 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.09974 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.08726 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.08473 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.11402 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.09968 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.11607 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.05482 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05838 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0679 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05693 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0653 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0565 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06144 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05978 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06908 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06631 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06331 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.09753 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05417 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.07929 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06255 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07889 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.02013 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0215 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02248 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02108 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02243 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02148 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02155 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02144 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02261 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02502 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02394 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02897 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.022 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02727 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02349 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02805 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{max} 0.03262 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03483 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03697 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03385 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03648 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03435 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.035 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03487 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03781 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04037 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03849 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05152 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0357 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0443 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03754 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04542 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    ASAE 0.01281 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01235 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01271 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01282 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01267 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01243 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01232 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01213 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01387 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01723 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01581 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02473 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01382 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01923 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01498 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01922 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    \sum Ranks 17 ^{\{ 1 \}} 47 ^{\{ 5 \}} 92 ^{\{ 10 \}} 34.5 ^{\{ 2 \}} 81 ^{\{ 8 \}} 39 ^{\{ 4 \}} 62 ^{\{ 7 \}} 50 ^{\{ 6 \}} 85 ^{\{ 9 \}} 115 ^{\{ 14 \}} 101 ^{\{ 12 \}} 105.5 ^{\{ 13 \}} 35 ^{\{ 3 \}} 133 ^{\{ 15 \}} 93 ^{\{ 11 \}} 134 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    200 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.03004 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03076 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03085 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03037 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.03139 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03094 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03282 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03037 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.02938 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03559 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03323 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02991 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02875 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03858 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03377 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04069 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.07131 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.07797 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.08532 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.07373 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08203 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.07759 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.08374 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.07738 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08435 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.08421 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08068 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.13489 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.07469 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.10571 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.08089 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.1039 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00142 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00152 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00157 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00146 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00154 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00149 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00167 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00144 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00136 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00206 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00183 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00145 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00134 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00244 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00186 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00262 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00803 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00955 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01194 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00849 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01055 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0093 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01118 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0094 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01153 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01156 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01033 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0292 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00975 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01744 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01012 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0172 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.07511 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0769 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07713 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07591 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.07847 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.07735 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.08205 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07593 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.07344 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08898 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.08307 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.07478 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07188 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.09646 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.08444 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.10173 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04754 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05198 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05688 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04915 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05469 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05173 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05583 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05159 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05623 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05614 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05379 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08993 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04979 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07047 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05393 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06927 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01811 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01815 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01899 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.018 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01939 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01845 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01901 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01828 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01873 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02142 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02013 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02676 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01806 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0234 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0203 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02478 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{max} 0.02912 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02943 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03145 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02902 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03166 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02977 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03086 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02976 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03113 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03446 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03244 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04814 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02955 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03829 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03269 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04011 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    ASAE 0.01084 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01041 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01058 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01075 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01055 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01059 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01044 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01026 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01183 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0146 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01356 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02271 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01181 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01657 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.013 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01652 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    \sum Ranks 27 ^{\{ 1 \}} 48 ^{\{ 5 \}} 87 ^{\{ 10 \}} 31.5 ^{\{ 3 \}} 80 ^{\{ 8 \}} 56 ^{\{ 6 \}} 82 ^{\{ 9 \}} 38.5 ^{\{ 4 \}} 66 ^{\{ 7 \}} 115 ^{\{ 14 \}} 92 ^{\{ 11 \}} 107 ^{\{ 13 \}} 30 ^{\{ 2 \}} 133 ^{\{ 15 \}} 97 ^{\{ 12 \}} 134 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    300 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.02485 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02476 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02566 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02457 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02581 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02534 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02574 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02419 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02525 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02979 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02852 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02323 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02369 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03294 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02815 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03398 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.0589 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06119 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.07198 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05917 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07063 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06366 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06554 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06125 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0723 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.07294 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06713 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.11461 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0585 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.08189 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.06684 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.08506 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00097 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00095 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00104 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00092 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00106 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00101 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00102 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00092 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00099 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00142 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0013 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00086 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00092 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00174 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00123 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0018 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00544 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00596 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0081 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00531 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00802 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0062 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00676 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00587 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00807 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00845 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00716 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0214 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00613 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01057 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00699 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01123 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.06213 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06189 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06414 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06142 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06453 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06335 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06434 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06047 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06312 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07448 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.07131 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05807 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05923 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08235 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.07037 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.08494 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03927 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04079 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04799 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03945 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04709 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04244 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0437 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04083 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0482 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04863 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04475 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.07641 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.039 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0546 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04456 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05671 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.0149 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01502 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01526 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01465 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01538 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01498 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01496 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.015 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01612 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01796 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0173 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02158 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01508 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01984 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0167 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02037 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{max} 0.02397 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02433 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02518 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02351 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02527 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02418 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0243 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02439 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02685 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02907 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02777 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0393 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02464 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0321 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02686 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03302 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    ASAE 0.00853 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00807 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00855 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00844 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00828 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00845 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00818 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00806 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00936 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01155 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01074 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01805 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00913 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0133 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01033 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01291 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    \sum Ranks 35 ^{\{ 3 \}} 40 ^{\{ 5 \}} 86 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 25 ^{\{ 1 \}} 85 ^{\{ 8 \}} 55 ^{\{ 6 \}} 60 ^{\{ 7 \}} 34 ^{\{ 2 \}} 86 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 120 ^{\{ 14 \}} 102 ^{\{ 13 \}} 99 ^{\{ 12 \}} 37 ^{\{ 4 \}} 130 ^{\{ 15 \}} 93 ^{\{ 11 \}} 137 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    450 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.02044 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02051 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02116 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.019 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02069 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02027 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02203 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0205 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02016 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02427 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02322 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01969 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01982 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02696 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02321 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02623 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04846 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05228 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0574 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04793 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05487 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05183 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05454 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04955 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0563 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05671 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05567 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0905 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04917 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06732 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05414 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06462 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00067 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00066 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.00069 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00058 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00067 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00064 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00075 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00067 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00065 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00091 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00083 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00061 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00066 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 0.00118 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00084 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0011 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00365 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00428 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00512 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0036 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00482 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00412 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00455 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00393 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00511 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00524 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00483 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01351 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00454 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00711 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00458 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00678 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.0511 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05128 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05289 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04749 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05174 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05068 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05506 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05125 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05041 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06067 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05805 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04922 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04954 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06741 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05803 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06557 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03231 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03485 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03827 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03195 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03658 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03456 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03636 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03303 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03753 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03781 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03711 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06033 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03278 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04488 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03609 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04308 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01212 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01221 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01301 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01152 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01267 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01213 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01268 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01239 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01284 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01464 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01405 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01779 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01241 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01646 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01395 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01616 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.01948 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01977 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02134 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01866 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02076 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01973 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02045 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01998 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02125 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0235 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02262 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03211 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02026 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02686 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02237 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02617 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00666 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0065 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00668 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00664 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00653 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00681 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00645 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00643 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0072 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00914 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00857 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01371 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00731 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01032 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00804 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01033 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 36 ^{\{ 2 \}} 49.5 ^{\{ 6 \}} 95 ^{\{ 11 \}} 13 ^{\{ 1 \}} 72 ^{\{ 7.5 \}} 41 ^{\{ 3 \}} 73 ^{\{ 9 \}} 44 ^{\{ 4 \}} 72 ^{\{ 7.5 \}} 118 ^{\{ 14 \}} 104 ^{\{ 13 \}} 102 ^{\{ 12 \}} 45.5 ^{\{ 5 \}} 137 ^{\{ 16 \}} 92 ^{\{ 10 \}} 130 ^{\{ 15 \}}

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 9.  Numerical values of simulation measures for \delta = 2.0, \gamma = 0.75 .
    n Est. MLE ADE CVME MPSE OLSE PCE RTADE WLSE LTADE MSADE MSALDE ADSOE KE MSSD MSSLD MSLND
    20 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.3501 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.3437 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.40963 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.30095 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.39118 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.33084 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.33466 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.32993 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.42136 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.32471 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.35322 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.50199 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.24141 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.38085 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.324 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.38994 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.13283 ^{\{ 7.5 \}} 0.12262 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.1403 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 0.11926 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.13649 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.15974 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.12869 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.13283 ^{\{ 7.5 \}} 0.1403 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 0.14078 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.13085 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.15005 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.12789 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.16161 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.12295 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.16948 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.24075 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.21192 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.3003 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.14184 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.25737 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.18243 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.2025 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.18359 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.31963 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.18816 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.208 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.4098 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.13207 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.21903 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.18787 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.22378 ^{\{ 11 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.02909 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02497 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03288 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02105 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02988 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03944 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02878 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02797 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03213 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03099 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02507 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03542 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.028 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03951 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02414 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04133 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.17505 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.17185 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.20481 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.15047 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.19559 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.16542 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.16733 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.16497 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.21068 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.16236 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.17661 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.25099 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.12071 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.19042 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.162 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.19497 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.17711 ^{\{ 7.5 \}} 0.16349 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.18707 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.15901 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.18198 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.21299 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.17159 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.17711 ^{\{ 7.5 \}} 0.18706 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.1877 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.17447 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.20007 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.17052 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.21549 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.16393 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.22597 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.0565 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05712 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05886 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05687 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06327 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06941 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05914 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05897 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05881 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06741 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06656 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06374 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05703 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07132 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05801 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.07227 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    D_{max} 0.09202 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09177 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.09715 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.08966 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.10075 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.11042 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.09523 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09403 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0975 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10556 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.10428 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.10641 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09022 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.11373 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.09277 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.1168 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    ASAE 0.0449 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04202 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04466 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04118 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04475 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03873 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03903 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04015 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05109 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05226 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04966 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07747 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04731 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06494 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04801 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06415 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    \sum Ranks 66 ^{\{ 7 \}} 44 ^{\{ 4 \}} 96.5 ^{\{ 12 \}} 16 ^{\{ 1 \}} 93 ^{\{ 11 \}} 86 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 56 ^{\{ 6 \}} 51 ^{\{ 5 \}} 103.5 ^{\{ 13 \}} 86 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 78 ^{\{ 8 \}} 127 ^{\{ 15 \}} 31 ^{\{ 2 \}} 122 ^{\{ 14 \}} 39 ^{\{ 3 \}} 129 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    70 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.17171 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.18705 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.20507 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.15645 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.19235 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.17397 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.17091 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.17337 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.2287 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.18551 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.18797 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.35752 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.14934 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.22252 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.16562 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.23357 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.06108 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06501 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07395 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0626 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.07357 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.09167 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06922 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06717 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.07612 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08148 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06963 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.10063 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.06762 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.08679 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0654 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09097 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.04867 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05793 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.07313 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03837 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06261 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04746 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05063 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0502 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.08989 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05706 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0566 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.21988 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04548 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0789 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04538 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09541 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.006 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00682 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00895 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00595 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00885 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01323 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00798 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00709 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00943 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00748 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01549 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00765 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01163 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00689 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01282 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.08586 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.09353 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10253 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.07822 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09617 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08699 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08546 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08669 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.11435 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.09276 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.09399 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.17876 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.07467 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.11126 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.08281 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.11679 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.08144 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.08668 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0986 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.08346 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09809 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.12223 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0923 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08956 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.10149 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.10863 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.09284 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.13417 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.09016 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.11572 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0872 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.12129 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.03009 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03133 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03149 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03058 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03206 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03927 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03093 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03076 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03394 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03862 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03514 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04015 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0298 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04024 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0338 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04049 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    D_{max} 0.0487 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05096 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05222 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0488 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05211 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0631 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0503 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04996 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05648 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06186 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05645 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.07057 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04803 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06548 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05377 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0661 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    ASAE 0.01898 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01867 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02002 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01877 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01966 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01889 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01739 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01873 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02301 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02448 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02275 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03954 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02094 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02842 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02149 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02845 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    \sum Ranks 29 ^{\{ 2 \}} 51 ^{\{ 7 \}} 89 ^{\{ 10 \}} 20 ^{\{ 1 \}} 82 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 94 ^{\{ 11 \}} 48 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 44 ^{\{ 4 \}} 108 ^{\{ 13 \}} 98 ^{\{ 12 \}} 82 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 142 ^{\{ 16 \}} 35 ^{\{ 3 \}} 121 ^{\{ 14 \}} 48 ^{\{ 5.5 \}} 133 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    150 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.10986 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.12035 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.13735 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.11316 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.13179 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.11926 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.12475 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.11964 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.15345 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.1338 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.12831 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.25651 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.11174 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.15491 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.11768 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.15252 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04272 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04461 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04968 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04411 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04973 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06877 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04602 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04415 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05031 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05342 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04797 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07337 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04901 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0609 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04463 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06118 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.02001 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02339 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03028 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01951 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02911 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02197 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02439 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02325 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03819 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02853 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02588 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10809 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02284 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03913 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02198 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03683 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00289 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0032 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00395 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0029 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0039 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00751 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00335 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00309 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00402 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00443 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00362 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00858 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00387 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00569 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00308 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00564 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.05493 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06017 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06868 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05658 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06589 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05963 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06238 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05982 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.07672 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0669 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06416 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.12826 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05587 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.07745 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05884 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.07626 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.05696 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05947 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06624 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05882 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0663 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.09169 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06136 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05886 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06708 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07123 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06396 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09782 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.06535 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0812 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05951 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.08157 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.02101 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02172 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02246 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02098 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02175 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02787 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0214 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02032 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02305 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02584 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02481 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02861 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02131 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02731 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02247 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02764 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.03392 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03507 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03694 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03388 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03583 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04538 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03497 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03315 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03822 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04156 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03964 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05122 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03487 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04466 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03605 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04506 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.01131 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01145 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01219 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01132 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01215 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01202 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01066 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01124 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01443 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.015 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01418 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02725 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01299 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01733 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01318 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01712 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 16 ^{\{ 1 \}} 51 ^{\{ 5 \}} 89 ^{\{ 10 \}} 21 ^{\{ 2 \}} 81 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 94 ^{\{ 11 \}} 53 ^{\{ 7 \}} 32 ^{\{ 3 \}} 107 ^{\{ 13 \}} 105 ^{\{ 12 \}} 81 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 144 ^{\{ 16 \}} 50 ^{\{ 4 \}} 126 ^{\{ 15 \}} 52 ^{\{ 6 \}} 122 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    200 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.09481 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09919 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.11951 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.09731 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.11266 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10231 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.10178 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.10627 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.12385 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.11765 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.11291 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.22789 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.09458 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.1277 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.10109 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.13459 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03406 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0368 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04226 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03738 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04238 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0608 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03909 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04036 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04193 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04674 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04094 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06563 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03914 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04865 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03897 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05024 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.01449 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01573 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02331 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01422 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02019 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01594 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01647 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01871 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02608 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02244 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01954 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.08519 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01677 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0256 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01579 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02858 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00188 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00215 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0029 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00212 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00277 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00588 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00242 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00265 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00286 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00333 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00259 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00697 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0026 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00368 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00236 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00394 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.0474 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04959 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05976 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04865 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05633 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05116 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05089 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05313 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06193 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05882 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05645 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.11394 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04729 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06385 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05055 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0673 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04541 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04906 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05635 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04984 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0565 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08107 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05213 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05382 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05591 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06232 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05458 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0875 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05219 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06487 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05196 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06698 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01776 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01728 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01877 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01808 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01905 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02479 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01893 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0192 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01888 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02278 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02095 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02556 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01809 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02331 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0194 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02489 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{max} 0.02854 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02811 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0311 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02911 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03125 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04038 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03059 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03114 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03133 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03661 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03376 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04569 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02932 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03781 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03112 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04026 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00922 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00948 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01031 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00924 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0102 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01022 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00873 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00939 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01165 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01246 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01166 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02331 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01082 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.014 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01085 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01438 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 15 ^{\{ 1 \}} 25 ^{\{ 3 \}} 86 ^{\{ 10 \}} 24 ^{\{ 2 \}} 82 ^{\{ 8 \}} 100 ^{\{ 12 \}} 46 ^{\{ 5 \}} 67 ^{\{ 7 \}} 95 ^{\{ 11 \}} 106 ^{\{ 13 \}} 85 ^{\{ 9 \}} 144 ^{\{ 16 \}} 45 ^{\{ 4 \}} 120 ^{\{ 14 \}} 53 ^{\{ 6 \}} 131 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    300 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.08175 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08302 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09584 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.08295 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0921 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.08157 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.08021 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08213 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.10482 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0976 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.08978 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.19508 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.07762 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.10747 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.08829 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.1103 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.02876 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03099 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0363 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03037 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03335 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04885 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03242 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03128 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03653 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03663 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03266 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05563 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03243 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04199 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03326 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04146 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.01057 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 0.01109 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01455 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01057 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 0.0136 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01075 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01013 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01096 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01746 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01501 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01281 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06142 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01129 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01861 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01214 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0188 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00135 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00144 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00207 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0014 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00178 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0038 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00168 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00159 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00206 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0021 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0017 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 0.00496 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00174 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00276 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0017 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 0.00266 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.04088 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04151 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04792 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04148 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04605 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04078 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04011 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04106 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05241 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0488 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04489 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.09754 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03881 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05373 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04415 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05515 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03835 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04132 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04839 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04049 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04447 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06514 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04322 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04171 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0487 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04883 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04355 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07418 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04324 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05599 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04435 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05528 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01451 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01492 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01568 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01477 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0151 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01945 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01508 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01474 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01613 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01734 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01679 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02148 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01519 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02013 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01651 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01986 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.02346 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02414 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02588 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02383 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02478 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03171 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02446 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02401 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02676 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02813 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02693 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03855 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02454 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03263 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02665 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03221 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00718 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0073 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0079 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00719 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00773 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00792 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00677 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0072 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00891 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00949 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00892 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01824 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0082 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01104 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00845 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01089 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 17.5 ^{\{ 1 \}} 42 ^{\{ 5 \}} 87 ^{\{ 10 \}} 28.5 ^{\{ 2 \}} 76 ^{\{ 8 \}} 89 ^{\{ 11 \}} 31 ^{\{ 3 \}} 36 ^{\{ 4 \}} 101 ^{\{ 12 \}} 109 ^{\{ 13 \}} 81.5 ^{\{ 9 \}} 144 ^{\{ 16 \}} 51 ^{\{ 6 \}} 129 ^{\{ 15 \}} 75.5 ^{\{ 7 \}} 126 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    450 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.06326 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06783 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.07928 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06463 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07265 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06995 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06595 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06897 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.08425 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.07847 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0712 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.16761 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0639 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09041 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06952 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08633 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.02415 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02646 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02954 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02364 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02695 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04121 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02631 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02548 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02907 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03157 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02792 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04678 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02769 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03356 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02597 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03406 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.00636 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00728 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00986 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00632 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00858 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00755 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0067 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0074 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01125 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01001 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00807 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04645 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00729 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01315 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00764 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01145 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00094 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00109 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0014 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00087 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00117 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00268 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00112 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00102 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00134 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00149 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00121 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00357 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00126 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00178 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00106 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00182 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.03163 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03391 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03964 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03231 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03632 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03497 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03298 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03448 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04212 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03923 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0356 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.0838 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03195 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0452 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03476 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04317 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03221 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03528 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03939 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03151 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03594 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05495 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03508 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03398 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03876 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04209 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03723 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06237 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03693 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04475 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03463 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04542 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.0121 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01181 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01305 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01242 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01266 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01607 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01218 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01194 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01264 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01499 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01383 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01823 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01233 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01656 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0127 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01614 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.01946 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01932 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02156 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01984 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02063 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02631 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01983 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01948 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02102 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02419 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02228 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03279 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02009 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0268 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02052 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02612 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    ASAE 0.00557 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00566 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00609 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00547 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00601 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00632 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00522 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00555 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00684 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00742 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00691 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01457 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0063 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00851 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00659 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00841 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    \sum Ranks 19 ^{\{ 1 \}} 38 ^{\{ 5 \}} 95 ^{\{ 10 \}} 23 ^{\{ 2 \}} 73 ^{\{ 8 \}} 104 ^{\{ 12 \}} 36 ^{\{ 4 \}} 35 ^{\{ 3 \}} 96 ^{\{ 11 \}} 107 ^{\{ 13 \}} 87 ^{\{ 9 \}} 144 ^{\{ 16 \}} 53 ^{\{ 6 \}} 129 ^{\{ 15 \}} 60 ^{\{ 7 \}} 125 ^{\{ 14 \}}

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 10.  Numerical values of simulation measures for \delta = 3.5, \gamma = 0.5 .
    n Est. MLE ADE CVME MPSE OLSE PCE RTADE WLSE LTADE MSADE MSALDE ADSOE KE MSSD MSSLD MSLND
    20 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.77168 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.76809 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.84661 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.71596 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.80149 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.70339 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.78376 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.76067 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.91526 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.59993 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.77341 ^{\{ 9 \}} 1.05303 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.08104 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.87407 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.72763 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.87105 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.07775 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.07744 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08311 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08034 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08821 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.11802 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.08311 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.08311 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0899 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.08642 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.08946 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.08937 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05695 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.09847 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.08049 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.10753 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 1.06897 ^{\{ 12 \}} 1.02191 ^{\{ 9 \}} 1.21392 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.75581 ^{\{ 4 \}} 1.02667 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.68575 ^{\{ 2 \}} 1.07332 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.95724 ^{\{ 7 \}} 1.33596 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.70539 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.9149 ^{\{ 6 \}} 1.704 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04444 ^{\{ 1 \}} 1.02214 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.88171 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.99335 ^{\{ 8 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00998 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00969 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01129 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00947 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01163 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02198 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01154 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01096 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01247 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01137 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01187 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01205 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0054 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01413 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00999 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01611 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.22048 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.21945 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.24189 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.20456 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.229 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.20097 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.22393 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.21733 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.2615 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.17141 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.22097 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.30087 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02315 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.24973 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.20789 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.24887 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.15551 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.15488 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.16622 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.16068 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.17641 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.23603 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.16623 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.16621 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.1798 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.17283 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.17893 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.17875 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.1139 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.19694 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.16098 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.21507 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.05534 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.05541 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05593 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05852 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06269 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0826 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05677 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05553 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05914 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0676 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.06827 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06145 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05199 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0697 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05965 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.07496 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    D_{max} 0.08925 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.08825 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09159 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.09215 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09924 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.13153 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.09117 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.08925 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.09676 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10384 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.10725 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.1017 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07619 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.11139 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.09445 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.11954 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    ASAE 0.04532 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.04375 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04621 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04116 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05013 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03245 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03944 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04351 ^{\{ 3.5 \}} 0.06002 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04967 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04615 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09029 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05507 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06957 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04822 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07438 ^{\{ 15 \}}
    \sum Ranks 49.5 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 40 ^{\{ 3 \}} 78 ^{\{ 9 \}} 39 ^{\{ 2 \}} 95 ^{\{ 12 \}} 89 ^{\{ 10 \}} 70 ^{\{ 8 \}} 49.5 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 114 ^{\{ 13 \}} 67 ^{\{ 7 \}} 92 ^{\{ 11 \}} 119 ^{\{ 14 \}} 20 ^{\{ 1 \}} 122 ^{\{ 15 \}} 56 ^{\{ 6 \}} 124 ^{\{ 16 \}}
    70 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.38708 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.40421 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.51253 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.38794 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.44381 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.52357 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.39876 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.43209 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.54517 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.39048 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.42867 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.82893 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04895 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.48272 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.40594 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.46834 ^{\{ 11 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04102 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04177 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05133 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.04363 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.04774 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.08577 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04446 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04528 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.05104 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04919 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04746 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06662 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03025 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05524 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04573 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05577 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.26609 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.27429 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.45976 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.2416 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.3468 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.41142 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.28375 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.33729 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.50461 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.28832 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.30255 ^{\{ 8 \}} 1.1095 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01393 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.33799 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.25368 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.32081 ^{\{ 9 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00277 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00273 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00412 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00282 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.0036 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.01232 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00322 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00331 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00403 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00377 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0036 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.00664 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00148 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00468 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00314 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00483 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.11059 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.11549 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.14644 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.11084 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.1268 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.14959 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.11393 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.12345 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.15576 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.11156 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.12248 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.23684 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01399 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.13792 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.11598 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.13381 ^{\{ 11 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.08205 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08354 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.10265 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.08726 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09548 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.17154 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.08893 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.09056 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.10208 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.09837 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.09491 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.13324 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0605 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.11047 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09145 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.11155 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.0317 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03027 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03218 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03068 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03193 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0563 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03165 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03137 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03254 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03697 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03626 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03957 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02778 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03987 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.0337 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03879 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{max} 0.05069 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.049 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0534 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04924 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0517 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0913 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05088 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05097 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0543 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05856 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05761 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0694 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04102 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06417 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05397 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06242 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    ASAE 0.01744 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01873 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01989 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01707 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02058 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01739 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01678 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01793 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0238 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02182 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02093 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04535 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02255 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02846 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0197 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02686 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    \sum Ranks 29 ^{\{ 3 \}} 35 ^{\{ 4 \}} 100 ^{\{ 11 \}} 28 ^{\{ 2 \}} 81.5 ^{\{ 10 \}} 124 ^{\{ 15 \}} 43 ^{\{ 5 \}} 62 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 110 ^{\{ 12 \}} 80 ^{\{ 8 \}} 80.5 ^{\{ 9 \}} 138 ^{\{ 16 \}} 20 ^{\{ 1 \}} 118 ^{\{ 14 \}} 62 ^{\{ 6.5 \}} 113 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    150 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.25741 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.28723 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.33028 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.24728 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.32023 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.37796 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.27298 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.28018 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.37038 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.28436 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.27735 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.60911 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04457 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.34047 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.27329 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.33688 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.02775 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02945 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03249 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02752 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03128 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.0686 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03289 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03047 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03433 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03355 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0316 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.04711 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02136 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03692 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.03156 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03824 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.1146 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.13115 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.18661 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09363 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.16818 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.21627 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.12654 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.12824 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.2379 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.15009 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.12349 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.60562 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00764 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.16919 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.11448 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.1759 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00128 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00136 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00171 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 0.00115 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0016 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00786 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00171 ^{\{ 9.5 \}} 0.00146 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00193 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00181 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00154 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00345 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00073 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00213 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.0015 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00226 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.07355 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.08206 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.09437 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.07065 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.09149 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.10799 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.078 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.08005 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.10582 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.08124 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07924 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.17403 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01274 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.09728 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.07808 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.09625 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.0555 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0589 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.06498 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05505 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06256 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.13721 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.06579 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.06095 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.06866 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0671 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0632 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.09421 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04272 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.07383 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06313 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07647 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.02119 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02149 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02144 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0207 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02185 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04339 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02193 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02111 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02232 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02592 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02395 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02881 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01951 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02737 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.0241 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02658 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{max} 0.03411 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0349 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03544 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03309 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0358 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.07038 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03555 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03433 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03727 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04136 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03834 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.05089 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02905 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04409 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03852 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04319 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    ASAE 0.01006 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01056 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01175 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00993 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01159 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.01117 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00977 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01073 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01372 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01276 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01202 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.0259 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01249 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01489 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01124 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01515 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    \sum Ranks 29 ^{\{ 3 \}} 53 ^{\{ 5 \}} 82.5 ^{\{ 10 \}} 18 ^{\{ 1 \}} 73 ^{\{ 9 \}} 130 ^{\{ 15 \}} 59.5 ^{\{ 6 \}} 48 ^{\{ 4 \}} 110 ^{\{ 12 \}} 94 ^{\{ 11 \}} 70 ^{\{ 8 \}} 139 ^{\{ 16 \}} 19 ^{\{ 2 \}} 118 ^{\{ 13 \}} 62 ^{\{ 7 \}} 119 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    200 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.22738 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.24049 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.28374 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.22633 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.26335 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.32776 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.24123 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.24084 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.31328 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.23175 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.25422 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.55912 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04407 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.29393 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.24363 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.29313 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.02338 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02475 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02843 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02441 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02825 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06116 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02619 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02451 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02883 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02977 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0278 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0442 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01918 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03334 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.02696 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03238 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.08379 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.09431 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.13122 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.07612 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.11804 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.16318 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.09553 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.09299 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.16137 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.10525 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10263 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.50196 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00749 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.13579 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.09516 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.13114 ^{\{ 11 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00087 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00103 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00131 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00093 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00129 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00644 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00109 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00099 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00133 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00139 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00122 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00315 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00059 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00174 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00116 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00163 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.06497 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06871 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.08107 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.06467 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.07524 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.09365 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06892 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06881 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.08951 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.06621 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.07263 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.15975 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01259 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.08398 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06961 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.08375 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.04677 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04949 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05686 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04883 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0565 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.12232 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.05238 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04901 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05766 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05954 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05559 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0884 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03837 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06669 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05391 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06477 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01842 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01854 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.019 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.0174 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.019 ^{\{ 8.5 \}} 0.03963 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01868 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01819 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01897 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.02249 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02071 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02579 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01775 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02459 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01959 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02407 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{max} 0.02964 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03001 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.03123 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02815 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03104 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06416 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03029 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02958 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03168 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03573 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0332 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04634 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02642 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03964 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03162 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.03874 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    ASAE 0.00813 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00859 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00969 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00828 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00948 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00933 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00794 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00848 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01137 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01065 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00986 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02451 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01009 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01255 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00948 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01222 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    \sum Ranks 25 ^{\{ 3 \}} 45 ^{\{ 5 \}} 89.5 ^{\{ 11 \}} 21 ^{\{ 2 \}} 79.5 ^{\{ 8 \}} 131 ^{\{ 15 \}} 52 ^{\{ 6 \}} 38 ^{\{ 4 \}} 105 ^{\{ 12 \}} 89 ^{\{ 10 \}} 82 ^{\{ 9 \}} 139 ^{\{ 16 \}} 20 ^{\{ 1 \}} 124 ^{\{ 14 \}} 70 ^{\{ 7 \}} 114 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    300 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.18765 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.18622 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.23491 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.18334 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.22584 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.27554 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.19962 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.19495 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.26373 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.20076 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.21238 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.45699 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04033 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.24334 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.19542 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.23557 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.01932 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02075 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.023 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02042 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02281 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.05248 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02174 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02078 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02432 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02395 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02185 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03616 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01532 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0263 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02232 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02669 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.05495 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0567 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.09068 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.05069 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.08238 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.11574 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.06299 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.06252 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.11564 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.07554 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.06987 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.34711 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00682 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.09099 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.06187 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.08566 ^{\{ 11 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00059 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00068 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 0.00087 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00063 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00083 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00468 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00074 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00068 ^{\{ 4.5 \}} 0.00095 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00091 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.00076 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00211 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00038 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00107 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00078 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00111 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.05362 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05321 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.06712 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.05238 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.06452 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.07873 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.05703 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0557 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.07535 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05736 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.06068 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.13057 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01152 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.06953 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.05583 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.06731 ^{\{ 12 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03864 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04151 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.046 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04083 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.04562 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.10497 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.04347 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04157 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04865 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0479 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04369 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.07233 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.03065 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05259 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04465 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05338 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01481 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01449 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01601 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01499 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0154 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.03369 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01558 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01493 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01592 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01812 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01693 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.02121 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01395 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01943 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01589 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02021 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.02383 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.02354 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02633 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.02408 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02526 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.05415 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02519 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02434 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02657 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02892 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.02722 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03806 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02079 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.03138 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02564 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.03239 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00611 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00649 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00725 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00604 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00719 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00738 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00603 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00656 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0085 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00801 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00734 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01688 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00749 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00901 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00699 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00906 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 26 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 30.5 ^{\{ 4 \}} 91 ^{\{ 10 \}} 26 ^{\{ 2.5 \}} 77 ^{\{ 8 \}} 135 ^{\{ 15 \}} 53 ^{\{ 6 \}} 44.5 ^{\{ 5 \}} 110 ^{\{ 12 \}} 94 ^{\{ 11 \}} 78 ^{\{ 9 \}} 139 ^{\{ 16 \}} 19 ^{\{ 1 \}} 118 ^{\{ 13 \}} 63 ^{\{ 7 \}} 120 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    450 BIAS( \hat{\delta} ) 0.14464 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.16061 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.18023 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.14937 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.18915 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.23554 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.16553 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.15659 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.20892 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.1712 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.17003 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.37407 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03867 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.19508 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.16801 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.17316 ^{\{ 10 \}}
    BIAS( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.01548 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01727 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02006 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01612 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01949 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04544 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01815 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.01616 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01997 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01955 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01872 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.02942 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01273 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02202 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.01764 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.02132 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.03395 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04041 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.05534 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03453 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05704 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.08297 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04494 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03901 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.07116 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.05212 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.04508 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.21887 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0053 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.0597 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.04395 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04793 ^{\{ 9 \}}
    MSE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.00038 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.00047 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00062 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 4e-04 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.00059 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00338 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00052 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00042 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00063 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00062 ^{\{ 10.5 \}} 0.00055 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.00137 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00025 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00073 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.00049 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00069 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\delta} ) 0.04133 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.04589 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.0515 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.04268 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.05404 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0673 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.04729 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04474 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.05969 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.04891 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.04858 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.10688 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.01105 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.05574 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.048 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04947 ^{\{ 10 \}}
    MRE( \hat{\gamma} ) 0.03095 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.03454 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.04013 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.03224 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.03897 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.09089 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.03631 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.03232 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.03993 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.0391 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.03745 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.05885 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.02546 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.04404 ^{\{ 14 \}} 0.03528 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.04264 ^{\{ 13 \}}
    D_{abs} 0.01192 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01219 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.01323 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0121 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.01294 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.0284 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.0123 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01173 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.01327 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01469 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.01401 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01758 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01138 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.01587 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.01331 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.01633 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    D_{max} 0.01911 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.01981 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.02163 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.01954 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.02131 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.04566 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.02006 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.01902 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.02212 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.02353 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.0225 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.03148 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.01709 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.02571 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.02146 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.026 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    ASAE 0.00468 ^{\{ 3 \}} 0.0049 ^{\{ 5 \}} 0.00541 ^{\{ 9 \}} 0.00457 ^{\{ 4 \}} 0.00543 ^{\{ 7 \}} 0.00591 ^{\{ 16 \}} 0.00445 ^{\{ 6 \}} 0.00499 ^{\{ 2 \}} 0.0063 ^{\{ 10 \}} 0.00603 ^{\{ 12 \}} 0.00566 ^{\{ 11 \}} 0.01259 ^{\{ 15 \}} 0.00568 ^{\{ 1 \}} 0.00678 ^{\{ 13 \}} 0.00524 ^{\{ 8 \}} 0.0067 ^{\{ 14 \}}
    \sum Ranks 21 ^{\{ 2 \}} 43 ^{\{ 5 \}} 90.5 ^{\{ 10 \}} 41 ^{\{ 4 \}} 84 ^{\{ 9 \}} 135 ^{\{ 15 \}} 52 ^{\{ 6 \}} 32 ^{\{ 3 \}} 107 ^{\{ 12 \}} 93.5 ^{\{ 11 \}} 78 ^{\{ 8 \}} 138 ^{\{ 16 \}} 18 ^{\{ 1 \}} 121 ^{\{ 14 \}} 61 ^{\{ 7 \}} 109 ^{\{ 13 \}}

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Table 11.  Partial and overall ranks for all estimation methods of our proposed model.
    Parameter n MLE ADE CVME MPSE OLSE PCE RTADE WLSE LTADE MSADE MSALDE ADSOE KE MSSD MSSLD MSLND
    \delta=2.5, \gamma=4.0 20 7.0 6.0 13.0 1.0 11.0 2.0 9.0 4.5 12.0 8.0 10.0 15.0 3.0 14.0 4.5 16.0
    70 1.0 4.0 11.0 2.0 10.0 3.0 6.0 5.0 13.0 12.0 8.5 16.0 7.0 14.0 8.5 15.0
    150 1.0 3.0 9.0 2.0 11.0 4.0 6.0 5.0 13.0 12.0 10.0 16.0 8.0 15.0 7.0 14.0
    200 1.0 4.0 11.0 2.0 9.0 3.0 6.0 5.0 13.0 12.0 10.0 16.0 8.0 14.0 7.0 15.0
    300 1.0 4.0 8.0 3.0 11.0 2.0 5.0 6.0 12.0 13.0 9.0 16.0 10.0 15.0 7.0 14.0
    450 2.0 3.0 11.0 1.0 9.0 4.0 6.0 5.0 12.0 13.0 10.0 16.0 7.0 15.0 8.0 14.0
    \delta=0.8, \gamma=0.3 20 2.0 3.0 9.0 1.0 7.0 15.0 5.0 4.0 10.0 11.0 8.0 16.0 12.0 14.0 6.0 13.0
    70 4.0 2.0 8.5 5.0 7.0 15.0 3.0 1.0 8.5 12.0 10.0 16.0 11.0 13.0 6.0 14.0
    150 1.0 3.0 7.0 2.0 8.0 14.5 4.0 5.0 10.0 12.0 9.0 16.0 11.0 13.0 6.0 14.5
    200 3.0 1.0 7.0 4.0 6.0 15.0 5.0 2.0 10.0 12.0 9.0 16.0 11.0 13.0 8.0 14.0
    300 1.0 3.0 7.0 2.0 6.0 16.0 4.0 5.0 9.0 12.0 10.0 15.0 11.0 14.0 8.0 13.0
    450 3.0 2.0 6.0 1.0 7.0 16.0 5.0 4.0 11.0 12.0 10.0 15.0 8.0 13.0 9.0 14.0
    \delta=0.4, \gamma=1.5 20 3.0 1.5 12.0 5.0 8.5 4.0 8.5 6.0 10.0 11.0 13.0 14.0 1.5 15.0 7.0 16.0
    70 1.0 4.0 10.0 5.5 8.0 5.5 7.0 2.0 11.0 13.0 12.0 14.0 3.0 15.0 9.0 16.0
    150 1.0 5.0 10.0 2.0 8.0 4.0 7.0 6.0 9.0 14.0 12.0 13.0 3.0 15.0 11.0 16.0
    200 1.0 5.0 10.0 3.0 8.0 6.0 9.0 4.0 7.0 14.0 11.0 13.0 2.0 15.0 12.0 16.0
    300 3.0 5.0 9.5 1.0 8.0 6.0 7.0 2.0 9.5 14.0 13.0 12.0 4.0 15.0 11.0 16.0
    450 2.0 6.0 11.0 1.0 7.5 3.0 9.0 4.0 7.5 14.0 13.0 12.0 5.0 16.0 10.0 15.0
    \delta=2.0, \gamma=0.75 20 7.0 4.0 12.0 1.0 11.0 9.5 6.0 5.0 13.0 9.5 8.0 15.0 2.0 14.0 3.0 16.0
    70 2.0 7.0 10.0 1.0 8.5 11.0 5.5 4.0 13.0 12.0 8.5 16.0 3.0 14.0 5.5 15.0
    150 1.0 5.0 10.0 2.0 8.5 11.0 7.0 3.0 13.0 12.0 8.5 16.0 4.0 15.0 6.0 14.0
    200 1.0 3.0 10.0 2.0 8.0 12.0 5.0 7.0 11.0 13.0 9.0 16.0 4.0 14.0 6.0 15.0
    300 1.0 5.0 10.0 2.0 8.0 11.0 3.0 4.0 12.0 13.0 9.0 16.0 6.0 15.0 7.0 14.0
    450 1.0 5.0 10.0 2.0 8.0 12.0 4.0 3.0 11.0 13.0 9.0 16.0 6.0 15.0 7.0 14.0
    \delta=3.5, \gamma=0.5 20 4.5 3.0 9.0 2.0 12.0 10.0 8.0 4.5 13.0 7.0 11.0 14.0 1.0 15.0 6.0 16.0
    70 3.0 4.0 11.0 2.0 10.0 15.0 5.0 6.5 12.0 8.0 9.0 16.0 1.0 14.0 6.5 13.0
    150 3.0 5.0 10.0 1.0 9.0 15.0 6.0 4.0 12.0 11.0 8.0 16.0 2.0 13.0 7.0 14.0
    200 3.0 5.0 11.0 2.0 8.0 15.0 6.0 4.0 12.0 10.0 9.0 16.0 1.0 14.0 7.0 13.0
    300 2.5 4.0 10.0 2.5 8.0 15.0 6.0 5.0 12.0 11.0 9.0 16.0 1.0 13.0 7.0 14.0
    450 2.0 5.0 10.0 4.0 9.0 15.0 6.0 3.0 12.0 11.0 8.0 16.0 1.0 14.0 7.0 13.0
    \sum Ranks 69.0 119.5 293.0 67.0 258.0 289.5 179.0 128.5 333.5 351.5 293.5 456.0 157.5 428.0 220.0 436.5
    Overall Rank 2 3 10 1 8 9 6 4 12 13 11 16 5 14 7 15

     | Show Table
    DownLoad: CSV
    Figure 4.  Graphical representation for BIAS values presented in Table 6.
    Figure 5.  Graphical representation for MSE values presented in Table 6.
    Figure 6.  Graphical representation for MRE values presented in Table 6.
    Figure 7.  Graphical representation for D_{abs} and D_{max} values presented in Table 6.
    Figure 8.  Comparison between D_{abs} and D_{max} values presented in Table 6.
    Figure 9.  Graphical representation for ASAE values presented in Table 6.

    To demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed model, we have utilized two real-world datasets, one from agriculture and the other from medical sciences. The subsequent evaluation, application, and analysis of our model are detailed below. For the purpose of comparing our model, we selected several existing models that share similar characteristics and use HLD base function. The models chosen for this comparison include:

    ● The exponentiated generalized standard HLD (EGSHLD), developed by Cordeiro et al. [40].

    ● The exponentiated HLD, proposed by Seo and Kang [41].

    ● The Poisson generalized HLD (PGHLD), introduced by Muhammad and Liu [42].

    ● The Kumaraswamy HLD (KHLD), formulated by Usman et al. [43].

    ● The Type-Ⅱ half logistic Weibull distribution (HLWD), created by Hassan et al. [28].

    ● The PHLD, developed by Krishnarani [23].

    These models were selected for their relevance and compatibility with the HLD base function framework, providing a robust basis for comparison with our proposed model.

    First data:

    This dataset discusses the total milk production in the first birth of 107 cows from the SINDI race [44]. These cows are property of the Carnauba farm, which belongs to the Agropecuaria Manoel Dantas Ltda (AMDA), located in Taperoa City, Paraiba (Brazil).

    0.4365, 0.4260, 0.5140, 0.6907, 0.7471, 0.2605, 0.6196, 0.8781, 0.4990, 0.6058, 0.6891, 0.5770, 0.5394, 0.1479, 0.2356, 0.6012, 0.1525, 0.5483, 0.6927, 0.7261, 0.3323, 0.0671, 0.2361, 0.4800, 0.5707, 0.7131, 0.5853, 0.6768, 0.5350, 0.4151, 0.6789, 0.4576, 0.3259, 0.2303, 0.7687, 0.4371, 0.3383, 0.6114, 0.3480, 0.4564, 0.7804, 0.3406, 0.4823, 0.5912, 0.5744, 0.5481, 0.1131, 0.7290, 0.0168, 0.5529, 0.4530, 0.3891, 0.4752, 0.3134, 0.3175, 0.1167, 0.6750, 0.5113, 0.5447, 0.4143, 0.5627, 0.5150, 0.0776, 0.3945, 0.4553, 0.4470, 0.5285, 0.5232, 0.6465, 0.0650, 0.8492, 0.8147, 0.3627, 0.3906, 0.4438, 0.4612, 0.3188, 0.2160, 0.6707, 0.6220, 0.5629, 0.4675, 0.6844, 0.3413, 0.4332, 0.0854, 0.3821, 0.4694, 0.3635, 0.4111, 0.5349, 0.3751, 0.1546, 0.4517, 0.2681, 0.4049, 0.5553, 0.5878, 0.4741, 0.3598, 0.7629, 0.5941, 0.6174, 0.6860, 0.0609, 0.6488, 0.2747

    We applied basic exploratory data analysis techniques to examine the dataset under study, with the results displayed in Figure 10. The left side shows a box plot, while the right side presents a total-time-on-test (TTT) plot. From the box plot, we observed that the data is approximately normally distributed. To understand the nature of the hazard function, we used the TTT plot as described by Aarset [45]. The TTT plot reveals a concave curve, indicating that the hazard function is increasing.

    Figure 10.  Box and TTT plots of first data.

    Second data:

    The data presented by [46], characterized by right-skewness, represents the survival times of 121 breast cancer patients treated at a tertiary care center between 1929 and 1938.

    "0.3, 0.3, 4.0, 5.0, 5.6, 6.2, 6.3, 6.6, 6.8, 7.4, 7.5, 8.4, 8.4, 10.3, 11.0, 11.8, 12.2, 12.3, 13.5, 14.4, 14.4, 14.8, 15.5, 15.7, 16.2, 16.3, 16.5, 16.8, 17.2, 17.3, 17.5, 17.9, 19.8, 20.4, 20.9, 21.0, 21.0, 21.1, 23.0, 23.4, 23.6, 24.0, 24.0, 27.9, 28.2, 29.1, 30.0, 31.0, 31.0, 32.0, 35.0, 35.0, 37.0, 37.0, 37.0, 38.0, 38.0, 38.0, 39.0, 39.0, 40.0, 40.0, 40.0, 41.0, 41.0, 41.0, 42.0, 43.0, 43.0, 43.0, 44.0, 45.0, 45.0, 46.0, 46.0, 47.0, 48.0, 49.0, 51.0, 51.0, 51.0, 52.0, 54.0, 55.0, 56.0, 57.0, 58.0, 59.0, 60.0, 60.0, 60.0, 61.0, 62.0, 65.0, 65.0, 67.0, 67.0, 68.0, 69.0, 78.0, 80.0, 83.0, 88.0, 89.0, 90.0, 93.0, 96.0,103.0,105.0,109.0,109.0,111.0,115.0,117.0,125.0,126.0,127.0,129.0,129.0,139.0,154.0"

    Similarly, the results are presented in Figure 14 for the second dataset. A box plot is displayed on the left, and on the right, a TTT plot is shown. The box plot indicates that the data is right-skewed along with some outliers. The TTT plot reveals a concave curve, indicating that the hazard function is increasing.

    The parameters (\delta, \gamma) of the proposed distribution are estimated using the ML method, implemented through the 'maxLik' package as described by Henningsen and Toomet [47]. This estimation is performed using R programming software [48], with further details available in Lambert [49]. The aforementioned candidate distributions and the SPHLD also fit the studied datasets. The MLEs and their corresponding standard errors (SEs) are calculated, with the results presented in Tables 2 and 4, respectively. We have also displayed the profile log-likelihood plots for both parameters of the proposed model in Figures 11 and 15, respectively, for both datasets. These plots indicate that the parameter estimation through the ML method is unique and consistent. PP plots of the models under comparison of the first and second datasets are presented in Figures 13 and 17.

    Figure 11.  Profile log-likelihood plots of \delta and \gamma first data.
    Figure 12.  PDF and CDF plots of the models under comparison of the first data.
    Figure 13.  PP plots of the models under comparison of the first data.
    Figure 14.  Box and TTT plots of second data.
    Figure 15.  Profile log-likelihood plots of \delta and \gamma second data.
    Figure 16.  PDF and CDF plots of the models under comparison of the second data.
    Figure 17.  PP plots of the models under comparison of the second data.

    Model Selection

    To determine the best model among the candidates, we used several standard criteria: log-likelihood (-2\log L) , Akaike's information criterion (AIC), Bayesian information criterion (BIC), corrected AIC (CAIC), Hannan-Quinn information criterion (HQIC) and goodness-of-fit test statistics, including the Kolmogorov-Smirnov (KS) test, AD test, and CVM test. The corresponding p-values for these tests are denoted as p(KS) , p(AD) , and p(CVM) , respectively. The best model is identified by the smallest values of (-2\log L) , AIC, BIC, CAIC, HQIC, KS, AD, and CVM, and the largest p-values, as recommended by Burnham and Anderson [50].

    The results in Tables 3 and 5 show that the proposed SPHLD outperforms the other candidate models. This conclusion is further supported by the graphical representations of the fitted PDF and CDF shown in Figures 12 and 16, where the SPHLD provides the best fit for the data.

    Model Validation

    We calculated the KS distances between the fitted distribution function and the empirical distribution function for both datasets to evaluate the model's validity. The KS distances are 0.0635 and 0.0460, with corresponding p-values of 0.7812 and 0.9603, respectively. These calculations used the parameters estimated by the ML method. The results indicate that the SPHLD fits the data very well (see other metrics AD and CVM also in Tables 3 and 5).

    This work provides a significant contribution to the creation of a flexible trigonometric extension of the PHLD. In particular, we use properties from the sine-generated family of distributions to create a novel two-parameter lifespan model, called the SPHLD. The primary reason behind this is that asymmetric datasets may make the new distribution more useful for simulating lifespan phenomena. The distribution takes on a number of asymmetric form configurations, as seen by the density function graphs of the SPHLD. In addition, the hazard rate graphs of the SPHLD showed both monotonic rises and declines. Statistical properties of the SPHLD that are computed include the quantile function, moments, central moments, incomplete moments, and stress-strength reliability. The SPHLD parameters are estimated using several different classical estimating methods. To assess the consistency of the various estimates and identify the most accurate estimating strategy, a simulation study was conducted based on a few accuracy metrics. The SPHLD outperforms several other distributions, according to analyses of actual data. Simulation analysis consistently demonstrated that the maximum product spacing exhibited the highest accuracy among the selected estimation techniques, followed by the maximum likelihood method, making it the preferred method for parameter estimation. The current study's primary limitation is its only focus on traditional estimating techniques for model parameters, which depend on complete sample data. Future studies can examine both Bayesian and traditional parameter estimation methods, with an emphasis on how they could be used in ranked set sampling.

    The authors declare they have not used Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools in the creation of this article.

    This research is supported by researchers Supporting Project number (RSPD2025R548), King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia.

    The authors declare there are no conflicts of interest.



    [1] M. Yavuz, T. A. Sulaiman, F. Usta, H. Bulut, Analysis and numerical computations of the fractional regularized long-wave equation with damping term, Math. Methods Appl. Sci., 44 (2021), 7538–7555. https://doi.org/10.1002/mma.6343 doi: 10.1002/mma.6343
    [2] S. Kumar, S. Ghosh, B. Samet, E. F. Doungmo Goufo, An analysis for heat equations arises in diffusion process using new Yang-Abdel-Aty-Cattani fractional operator, Math. Methods Appl. Sci., 43 (2020), 6062–6080. https://doi.org/10.1002/mma.6347 doi: 10.1002/mma.6347
    [3] E. F. Doungmo Goufo, S. Kumar, Shallow water wave models with and without singular kernel: existence, uniqueness, and similarities, Math. Probl. Eng., 2017 (2017), 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1155/2017/4609834 doi: 10.1155/2017/4609834
    [4] M. Yavuz, Characterizations of two different fractional operators without singular kernel, Math. Model. Nat. Phenom., 14 (2019), 302. https://doi.org/10.1051/mmnp/2018070 doi: 10.1051/mmnp/2018070
    [5] E. F. Doungmo Goufo, S. Kumar, S. B. Mugisha, Similarities in a fifth-order evolution equation with and with no singular kernel, Chaos Solitons Fract., 130 (2020), 109467. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2019.109467 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2019.109467
    [6] R. Subashini, K. Jothimani, K. S. Nisar, C. Ravichandran, New results on nonlocal functional integro-differential equations via Hilfer fractional derivative, Alex. Eng. J., 59 (2020), 2891–2899. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aej.2020.01.055 doi: 10.1016/j.aej.2020.01.055
    [7] H. Bulut, H. M. Baskonus, Y. Pandir, The modified trial equation method for fractional wave equation and time fractional generalized Burgers equation, Abstr. Appl. Anal., 2013 (2013), 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1155/2013/636802 doi: 10.1155/2013/636802
    [8] J. H. He, Approximate analytical solution for seepage flow with fractional derivatives in porous media, Comput. Methods Appl. Mech. Eng., 167 (1998), 57–68. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0045-7825(98)00108-x doi: 10.1016/s0045-7825(98)00108-x
    [9] V. P. Dubey, R. Kumar, D. Kumar, A hybrid analytical scheme for the numerical computation of time fractional computer virus propagation model and its stability analysis, Chaos Solitons Fract., 133 (2020), 109626. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2020.109626 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2020.109626
    [10] S. Kumar, Y. Khan, A. Yildirim, A mathematical modeling arising in the chemical systems and its approximate numerical solution, Asia Pac. J. Chem. Eng., 7 (2012), 835–840. https://doi.org/10.1002/apj.647 doi: 10.1002/apj.647
    [11] J. Singh, D. Kumar, S. D. Purohit, A. M. Mishra, M. Bohra, An efficient numerical approach for fractional multidimensional diffusion equations with exponential memory, Numer. Methods Partial Differ. Equ., 37 (2021), 1631–1651. https://doi.org/10.1002/num.22601 doi: 10.1002/num.22601
    [12] M. Caputo, Linear models of dissipation whose Q is almost frequency independent–Ⅱ, Geophys. J. Int., 13 (1967), 529–539. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-246x.1967.tb02303.x doi: 10.1111/j.1365-246x.1967.tb02303.x
    [13] Z. Li, C. Huang, B. J. Wang, Phase portrait, bifurcation, chaotic pattern and optical soliton solutions of the Fokas-Lenells equation with cubic-quartic dispersion in optical fibers, Phys. Lett. A, 465 (2023), 128714. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physleta.2023.128714 doi: 10.1016/j.physleta.2023.128714
    [14] M. S. Ullah, Interaction solution to the (3+1)-D negative-order KdV first structure, Partial Differ. Equ. Appl. Math., 8 (2023), 100566. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.padiff.2023.100566 doi: 10.1016/j.padiff.2023.100566
    [15] A. L. Hodgkin, A. F. Huxley, A quantitative description of membrane current and its application to conduction and excitation in nerve, J. Physiol., 117 (1952), 500–544. https://doi.org/10.1113/jphysiol.1952.sp004764 doi: 10.1113/jphysiol.1952.sp004764
    [16] M. S. Ullah, D. Baleanu, M. Z. Ali, H. O. Roshid, Novel dynamics of the Zoomeron model via different analytical methods, Chaos Solitons Fract., 174 (2023), 113856. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2023.113856 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2023.113856
    [17] M. H. Protter, H. F. Weinberger, Maximum principles in differential equations, New York: Springer, 1984. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4612-5282-5
    [18] M. Schatzman, J. Taylor, Numerical analysis: a mathematical introduction, Oxford University Press, 2002. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198502791.001.0001
    [19] J. W. Thomas, Numerical partial differential equations: finite difference methods, New York: Springer, 1995. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4899-7278-1
    [20] K. George, E. H. Twizell, Stable second-order finite-difference methods for linear initial-boundary-value problems, Appl. Math. Lett., 19 (2006), 146–154. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aml.2005.04.003 doi: 10.1016/j.aml.2005.04.003
    [21] K. Nonlaopon, A. M. Alsharif, A. M. Zidan, A. Khan, Y. S. Hamed, R. Shah, Numerical investigation of fractional-order Swift-Hohenberg equations via a novel transform, Symmetry, 13 (2021), 1–21. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym13071263 doi: 10.3390/sym13071263
    [22] J. G. Liu, X. J. Yang, Symmetry group analysis of several coupled fractional partial differential equations, Chaos Solitons Fract., 173 (2023), 113603. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2023.113603 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2023.113603
    [23] A. H. Ganie, M. M. AlBaidani, A. Khan, A comparative study of the fractional partial differential equations via novel transform, Symmetry, 15 (2023), 1–21. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym15051101 doi: 10.3390/sym15051101
    [24] J. G. Liu, Y. F. Zhang, J. J. Wang, Investigation of the time fractional generalized (2 + 1)-dimensional Zakharov-Kuznetsov equation with single-power law nonlinearity, Fractals, 31 (2023), 2350033. https://doi.org/10.1142/s0218348x23500330 doi: 10.1142/s0218348x23500330
    [25] A. H. Ganie, F. Mofarreh, A. Khan, A fractional analysis of Zakharov-Kuznetsov equations with the Liouville-Caputo operator, Axioms, 12 (2023), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.3390/axioms12060609 doi: 10.3390/axioms12060609
    [26] M. M. AlBaidani, A. H. Ganie, F. Aljuaydi, A. Khan, Application of analytical techniques for solving fractional physical models arising in applied sciences, Fractal Fract., 7 (2023), 1–19. https://doi.org/10.3390/fractalfract7080584 doi: 10.3390/fractalfract7080584
    [27] J. G. Liu, X. J. Yang, L. L. Geng, X. J. Yu, On fractional symmetry group scheme to the higher-dimensional space and time fractional dissipative Burgers equation, Int. J. Geom. Methods Modern Phys., 19 (2022), 2250173. https://doi.org/10.1142/s0219887822501730 doi: 10.1142/s0219887822501730
    [28] J. Azevedo, C. Cuevas, E. Henriquez, Existence and asymptotic behaviour for the time-fractional Keller-Segel model for chemotaxis, Math. Nachr., 292 (2019), 462–480. https://doi.org/10.1002/mana.201700237 doi: 10.1002/mana.201700237
    [29] C. Peng, Z. Li, Soliton solutions and dynamics analysis of fractional Radhakrishnan-Kundu-Lakshmanan equation with multiplicative noise in the Stratonovich sense, Results Phys., 53 (2023), 106985. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rinp.2023.106985 doi: 10.1016/j.rinp.2023.106985
    [30] N. A. Zabidi, Z. A. Majid, A. Kilicman, F. Rabiei, Numerical solutions of fractional differential equations by using fractional explicit Adams method, Mathematics, 8 (2020), 1–23. https://doi.org/10.3390/math8101675 doi: 10.3390/math8101675
    [31] J. S. Duan, T. Chaolu, R. Rach, Solutions of the initial value problem for nonlinear fractional ordinary differential equations by the Rach-Adomian-Meyers modified decomposition method, Appl. Math. Comput., 218 (2012), 8370–8392. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amc.2012.01.063 doi: 10.1016/j.amc.2012.01.063
    [32] T. Botmart, R. P. Agarwal, M. Naeem, A. Khan, R. Shah, On the solution of fractional modified Boussinesq and approximate long wave equations with non-singular kernel operators, AIMS Math., 7 (2022), 12483–12513. https://doi.org/10.3934/math.2022693 doi: 10.3934/math.2022693
    [33] N. A. Shah, Y. S. Hamed, K. M. Abualnaja, J. D. Chung, R. Shah, A. Khan, A comparative analysis of fractional-order Kaup-Kupershmidt equation within different operators, Symmetry, 14 (2022), 1–23. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym14050986 doi: 10.3390/sym14050986
    [34] D. Fathima, R. A. Alahmadi, A. Khan, A. Akhter, A. H. Ganie, An efficient analytical approach to investigate fractional Caudrey-Dodd-gibbon equations with non-singular kernel derivatives, Symmetry, 15 (2023), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym15040850 doi: 10.3390/sym15040850
    [35] H. Jafari, H. Tajadodi, D. Baleanu, A. Al-Zahrani, Y. Alhamed, A. Zahid, Fractional sub-equation method for the fractional generalized reaction Duffing model and nonlinear fractional Sharma-Tasso-Olver equation, Open Phys., 11 (2013), 1482–1486. https://doi.org/10.2478/s11534-013-0203-7 doi: 10.2478/s11534-013-0203-7
    [36] N. K. Mishra, M. M. AlBaidani, A. Khan, A. H. Ganie, Two novel computational techniques for solving nonlinear time-fractional Lax's Korteweg-de Vries equation, Axioms, 12 (2023), 1–13. https://doi.org/10.3390/axioms12040400 doi: 10.3390/axioms12040400
    [37] A. M. Wazwaz, The tanh method: exact solutions of the sine-Gordon and the sinh-Gordon equations, Appl. Math. Comput., 167 (2005), 1196–1210. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.amc.2004.08.005 doi: 10.1016/j.amc.2004.08.005
    [38] N. K. Mishra, M. M. AlBaidani, A. Khan, A. H. Ganie, Numerical investigation of time-fractional Phi-four equation via novel transform, Symmetry, 15 (2023), 1–18. https://doi.org/10.3390/sym15030687 doi: 10.3390/sym15030687
    [39] W. H. Deng, Finite element method for the space and time fractional Fokker-Planck equation, SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 47 (2009), 204–226. https://doi.org/10.1137/080714130 doi: 10.1137/080714130
    [40] M. K. Alaoui, R. Fayyaz, A. Khan, R. Shah, M. S. Abdo, Analytical investigation of Noyes-Field model for time-fractional Belousov-Zhabotinsky reaction, Complexity, 2021 (2021), 1–21. https://doi.org/10.1155/2021/3248376 doi: 10.1155/2021/3248376
    [41] A. M. Wazwaz, New solitary-wave special solutions with compact support for the nonlinear dispersive K(m, n) equations, Chaos Solitons Fract., 13 (2002), 321–330. https://doi.org/10.1016/s0960-0779(00)00249-6 doi: 10.1016/s0960-0779(00)00249-6
    [42] J. H. He, X. H. Wu, Exp-function method for nonlinear wave equations, Chaos Solitons Fract., 30 (2006), 700–708. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2006.03.020 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2006.03.020
    [43] J. H. He, X. H. Wu, Construction of solitary solution and compacton-like solution by variational iteration method, Chaos Solitons Fract., 29 (2006), 108–113. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2005.10.100 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2005.10.100
    [44] J. H. He, Some asymptotic methods for strongly nonlinear equations, Int. J. Modern Phys. B, 20 (2006), 1141–1199. https://doi.org/10.1142/s0217979206033796 doi: 10.1142/s0217979206033796
    [45] J. H. He, Application of homotopy perturbation method to nonlinear wave equations, Chaos Solitons Fract., 26 (2005), 695–700. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2005.03.006 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2005.03.006
    [46] M. Inc, New exact solitary pattern solutions of the nonlinearly dispersive R(m, n) equations, Chaos Solitons Fract., 29 (2006), 499–505. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2005.08.051 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2005.08.051
    [47] J. H. He, String theory in a scale dependent discontinuous space-time, Chaos Solitons Fract., 36 (2008), 542–545. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chaos.2007.07.093 doi: 10.1016/j.chaos.2007.07.093
    [48] I. Podlubny, M. Kacenak, Isoclinal matrices and numerical solution of fractional differential equations, In: 2001 European Control Conference (ECC), Portugal: Porto, 2001, 1467–1470. https://doi.org/10.23919/ecc.2001.7076125
    [49] X. J. Yang, D. Baleanu, H. M. Srivastava, Local fractional Laplace transform and applications, In: Local fractional integral transforms and their applications, Cambridge, MA, USA: Academic Press, 2016,147–178. https://doi.org/10.1016/b978-0-12-804002-7.00004-8
  • This article has been cited by:

    1. Murat Genç, Ömer Özbilen, Sine Unit Exponentiated Half-Logistic Distribution: Theory, Estimation, and Applications in Reliability Modeling, 2025, 13, 2227-7390, 1871, 10.3390/math13111871
  • Reader Comments
  • © 2024 the Author(s), licensee AIMS Press. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0)
通讯作者: 陈斌, bchen63@163.com
  • 1. 

    沈阳化工大学材料科学与工程学院 沈阳 110142

  1. 本站搜索
  2. 百度学术搜索
  3. 万方数据库搜索
  4. CNKI搜索

Metrics

Article views(1487) PDF downloads(52) Cited by(10)

Figures and Tables

Figures(6)  /  Tables(2)

Other Articles By Authors

/

DownLoad:  Full-Size Img  PowerPoint
Return
Return

Catalog